JUSTIFIED MAFIA - Day 7 (5 alive)

[President Jeff]

That. Maybe scum didn't send in a night kill?

[The Soul Of Philly]

They can do that?

[President Jeff]

Yah. Maybe the person doing the killing is a quiet inactive player who forgot to send in the night action

[C.J. Gates]

Alrighty, I'm back.

As some of you might have realized, I wasn't able to post on day three. I couldn't post because I was silenced night two. And because of this, it leads me to believe that the mafia have a jailkeeper-type role that silences people.

I say this because I find it incredibly hard to believe that James was silenced and then is killed the next night. I can't see the mafia pouncing on the thought of killing a quiet player who would have been modkilled if he weren't silenced. Sure, it's always possible, but one would assume that if James was simply not speaking, he would have been modkilled and the mafia would have gone with a different target. I believe they didn't because the jailkeeper is scum.

I can further this by saying that the reason the mafia didn't kill is because I was the target and I didn't die. I was protected last night and the mafia failed to kill me. They are trying to keep the whole jailkeep idea a secret by offing who they silence.

Of course this doesn't help us nail who is scum, it only shows us what kind of roles we are working against.

To speak on yesterday's activity...

I'm iffy on Chaz. Everything from him screams that of a guy who is either scum and found out, or desperate for...something. What strikes me as odd is that no one came out with a vote of suspicion on him and then he talks about how he visited James the night he died, out of the blue. I don't know if I fully believe his cop claim, because something between the mafia not killing him (he's a cop, so they'd want to get rid of power roles I'd assume) and the outing of information that probably wasn't going to come out, it just doesn't add up for me.

Out of yesterday, Caine got the most eyebrows raised from me. He seems very aggressive and I don't know if I know what to make of it. It seems like he was a bit too pushy on Chaz after everything happened, and was a bit flip floppy toward the end when he realized a lynch of Chaz wasn't going to happen. He's the one right now that I've got my eye on, but I'm going to withhold a vote until he speaks on this day phase.

[Michael Callahan]

I need one person to check in for the day and if they don't, I know who I'm casting my suspicions on.

[T-Marv]

Was gone most of the day. I'm back now.

No NK... We got lucky.

if chaz really is the Cop...I'm hoping he checked Caine.

[Michael Callahan]

CHECK IN LIST:

PLAYERS ALIVE
1. Kurt
2. President Jeff
3. Tmarv
4. Callahan
5. Level-One
6. Chaz
7. C.J. Gates
8. The Soul
9. Donovan Caine
10. Phil Atken
11. Johnny Rebel

[Level-Two]

Very interesting, CJ. I'll have more thoughts/information on this business tomorrow.

[Calvin Ingram]

Interesting modkill on Envi. Don't have any info for anyone. But I know I was wrong on Chaz for one and right on Atken.

[Kurt]

Wanted to let the game know I won't be available much this day. Taking care of my girlfriend as she recovers from surgery, so I won't be near a computer much and typing from my kindle is slow. I will do my best though.

If the silencing is true, which does have evidence in days 2, 3, and maybe 1, then the voting dynamic for today changes. With 11 left, 4 mafia and 1 possible silent, a lynch can only be achieved with full town support. I would be warry of anyone today that is barely here or stallsany attempt at a lynch.

Lets see who all checks in first, then we can move forward.

[C.J. Gates]

Jun 4, 2012 23:03:11 GMT -4 Michael Callahan said:

CHECK IN LIST:

PLAYERS ALIVE
1. Kurt
2. President Jeff
3. Tmarv
4. Callahan
5. Level-One
6. Chaz
7. C.J. Gates
8. The Soul
9. Donovan Caine
10. Phil Atken
11. Johnny Rebel

If my suspicion is right, one of them won't check in at all...so hopefully that one person isn't the one you're waiting on.

[C.J. Gates]

Jun 5, 2012 0:35:32 GMT -4 Kurt said:

Wanted to let the game know I won't be available much this day. Taking care of my girlfriend as she recovers from surgery, so I won't be near a computer much and typing from my kindle is slow. I will do my best though.

If the silencing is true, which does have evidence in days 2, 3, and maybe 1, then the voting dynamic for today changes. With 11 left, 4 mafia and 1 possible silent, a lynch can only be achieved with full town support. I would be warry of anyone today that is barely here or stallsany attempt at a lynch.

Lets see who all checks in first, then we can move forward.

I doubt there was a silence on day 1. Typically the role would only be able to be used the first night. That's why I think Goodburn was the first kill, because he was new to the game so no one could really read anything off of it.

[The Soul Of Philly]

It comes down to Rebel or Atken.

[Michael Callahan]

It's not. The guy I was looking at already checked in.

[T-Marv]

Jun 5, 2012 0:32:06 GMT -4 Calvin Ingram said:

Interesting modkill on Envi. Don't have any info for anyone. But I know I was wrong on Chaz for one and right on Atken.

How do you know?

Don't out yourself, but is this based on info or your own gut feeling which I don't trust.

YOu played a horrible day 3...just horrible. You went all apeshit on Caine and the SECOND he claimed cop you just let up and went "Oh, Never Mind I'm just gonna slowly wonder over here and never fully explain myself except for a bunch of nonsensical mumbling." You're simply the scummiest player in this game right now.

[Johnny Rebel]

Jun 5, 2012 7:32:49 GMT -4 Michael Callahan said:

It's not. The guy I was looking at already checked in.

Who were you looking for?

[Michael Callahan]

Jun 5, 2012 8:16:04 GMT -4 Johnny Rebel said:

Jun 5, 2012 7:32:49 GMT -4 Michael Callahan said:

It's not. The guy I was looking at already checked in.

Who were you looking for?

Level One.

I know who visited him last night so I figure if he was unable to post then we'd know who the jailkeeper is.

[C.J. Gates]

Jun 4, 2012 23:03:11 GMT -4 Michael Callahan said:

CHECK IN LIST:

PLAYERS ALIVE
1. Kurt
2. President Jeff
3. Tmarv
4. Callahan
5. Level-One
6. Chaz
7. C.J. Gates
8. The Soul
9. Donovan Caine
10. Phil Atken
11. Johnny Rebel

Amended your list.

The more I think on it, the more I'm starting to get the feeling that Chaz was silenced. What better way to keep the trend going then to silence the one power role that might be able to out them. The mafia was doing the whole silence-one-kill-them-the-next-night deal, so silencing Chaz (who claimed cop) is as good as a kill since he can't share his information.

I mean, it comes down to him or Atken, and given how active Chaz was last day phase, it wouldn't make sense for him to just disappear. Even if he was trying to keep the heat off of himself. If he's not, and he's actually scum laying low to appear silenced since I outed their plan, there's going to be a point where they will be prodded. We've already seen Farq modkill one inactive, so I'm sure it could happen again.

[T-Marv]

So... It's time to seriously do some scum hunting....

With the disappearance of Chaz (I'm assuming he's been silenced) I'm thinking that's good enough to clear him.

I'm liking Caine or Atken as a good lynch.

Caine because of his back and forth play and confusing flip flopping the last day period.

Atken because he's been very very quiet (I'm still suspicious of the quiet ones) which is normal of Atken, but IDK this one just has a wierd feel to it. His posts have just been "Hey, I'm here" and that's pretty crazy.

[The Soul Of Philly]

Callahan. Ive been thinking l1 was scum since day two. Posts enough not to even seem inactive and, if what was said about the mafia leader being experienced, it makes sense. I'm also on the Caine lynch wagon tho more incriminating evidnence

[Level-Two]

Time for the bomshells. ;D

I can confirm the town consists of

1.Chaz
2.Donovan Cain
3.CJ Gates
4.President Jeff

These four are near and in some cases 100% confirmed as town by me.

I am unsure in regards to others in terms of actual evidence but I'd also say based on gameplay and night results that corroborate eachother (CJ Gates is town – visited Kurt night one – Callahan says he saw him – none of this disputed. Which means one of them is scum or both of them are town)

5.Kurt Noble

Is also very likely to be town.

Now comes the fun time...

I can confirm that Phil Atken has the ability to kidnap and silence members of the town. As a result of CJ Gate's post – he silenced him last night. I am 99% that Phil Atken's role is scum aligned or he'd be targeting members in the game whom he felt had been scum (Donovain Caine?) – not random townies.

Vote: Phil Atken

I purposefully sat back and watched how the game was going to be played in attempt to read everyone else rather then throwing my information forward and allowing scum to skirt around it.

As for how do I have ALL this information? Let's just say my role isn't as useless as I thought and I have friends in high places.

So we have

TOWN
Chaz
Donovain Cain
CJ Gates
President jeff
Kurt Noble
Level-One

Scum:
Phil Atken

Which leaves

Johnny Rebel
Terry Marvin
Callahan
The Soul

I believe there are three scum in this game. On that list – Callahan has hinted tracker/watcher and should be held at the lowest priority there as no one has counter claimed.

Focus ALL investigations and night actions on those four individuals (mainly the 3, minus Callahan) and the game is the towns for the taking.

I personally believe the two remaining scum are Johnny Rebel and The Soul but I cannot confirm this with any certainty. I was suspicious about T-Marv but his post fingering Atken makes me feel a bit better where as...

Callahan. Ive been thinking l1 was scum since day two. Posts enough not to even seem inactive and, if what was said about the mafia leader being experienced, it makes sense. I'm also on the Caine lynch wagon tho more incriminating evidnence

A post like this really adds major suspicion considering I know what I know. ;D

ALSO, Callahan who visited me last night? The Soul? Terry? Johnny? Any of those three?

If I could get night protection after all this that would be SPLENDID!

Jules, also if you could shine my MVP award I'd appreciate it greatly. Thanks!

[T-Marv]

Nicely played L1... nicely played.

Not sure how I've come off as suspicious.... but you're entitled to your own opinion.

I'm still not certain of Caine...even though you say he's 100% not scum, but there's something bad about him that I don't like.

Chaz and Gates are definitive cause they were the ones kidnapped. Not sure how you're clearing Caine and Jeff... but I'll take your word on Jeff anyways.

the soul has rubbed me the wrong way from the beginning but I passed it off as inexperience. I got no read on Johnny or Callahan.

I think one of your town predictions is DEAD wrong and I'll just leave it at that for now.

Vote: Atken

[Level-Two]

Yeah, we'll take it one step at a time. I still have a bit more info that I am holding back as to the manner in which each person I have cleared got cleared.

Also, killing me won't stop the information from coming out... just so scum knows.

[Michael Callahan]

Vote: Atken

Seems legit to me.

[President Jeff]

I'm sold on Atkens

Vote: Atkens

[Calvin Ingram]

Vote:Atken

[Kurt]

I have a question to ask once I'm at my computer and can type everything out. Just gonna ask for a possible hammer tohold off for a few hours. Thanks.

[The Soul Of Philly]

Awesome. That was a waste.

Vote: Atken

[The Soul Of Philly]

EBWOP: Sorry Kurt I had opened this topic in a tab and then started dinner and came back and voted

[Level-Two]

Jun 5, 2012 17:43:31 GMT -4 The Soul Of Philly said:

Awesome. That was a waste.

Vote: Atken

Please bold your vote if you're going to throw your scum buddy under the bus.

Thanks!