|
|
Post by T-Marv on Oct 12, 2012 17:04:14 GMT -4
Okay folks....Here's what happened.
Rebel was the 5th vote....and doesnt count.
Jules was a 4th vote and is the hammer as Callahan is HATED and requires one less to lynch.
DEAD: Michael Callahan - John Mayer - Hated Town Bomb
And since Jules was the HAMMER
DEAD: Jules - Lindsay Lohan - Mafia Roleblocker
Night starts now... 24 hours.....7 alive.
|
|
|
|
Post by T-Marv on Oct 14, 2012 8:53:12 GMT -4
Sorry Guys, i had a crazy bad weekend. I'll have this going again this afternoon. Again, sorry for the delay.
|
|
|
|
Post by T-Marv on Oct 15, 2012 8:33:05 GMT -4
Sorry Guys. Not much of a write up today.
Family stuff came up and I'm barely around a PC.
DEAD: Johnny Rebel - Snookie - Town Mason
DEAD: Sally Talfourd - Justin Beiber - Mafia Janitor/Framer
With 5 Alive, it takes 3 to lynch
Alive:
Watson
Arcadia
AC Smith
JamesV
TJ
|
|
|
|
Post by A.C. Smith on Oct 15, 2012 8:45:48 GMT -4
Without a writeup to explain how both a townie and a scummie (catchy, huh?) got offed last night, I'm not going to go too far here with speculation since any number of things could have happened. Having said that, the previous day/night phase very nearly ended catastrophically for the town, but somehow, we're in a position to win this game. I wish I could say Callahan and I devised a master plan to use his bomb to take out a silent scummie, but we just got really, really, REALLY lucky on the mislynch. Credit to Jules for playing a really good game as scum and floating under EVERYONE'S radar. I apologize to Callahan for being wrong on who he was. Having said that, though, if you're reading this, you could have picked a better strategy to clear yourself than accusing a clearly-town player of being scum!  Anyway, here's what we've got. TOWN: A.C., JamesV THIRD PARTY: Watson UNKNOWN: TJ, Arcadia Given the tiff between Arcadia and Sally, I'm tempted to believe Arcadia is town, though I'll readily admit I'm not entirely convinced of it. I will not cast a vote yet, but for now... FOS: TJHe's been stone-silent since responding to my inquiry about the hammer on Knuckles, and provided nothing useful in that post. In fact, he tried to throw us off the scent regarding Sally, which now raises a red flag since she flipped scum. |
|
|
|
Post by Michael Jennings on Oct 15, 2012 9:45:37 GMT -4
I was actually going to vote for Jules over Callahan but the day phases ended before I could get back online. Luckily the Bomb did the work for me. Figured Sally was scum over Arcadia going by what was going on. Going to Vote: TJ because out of everyone left I think he's the highest probability of being scum.
|
|
|
|
Post by Nick Watson on Oct 15, 2012 10:12:43 GMT -4
Im gonna wait on throwing the hammer down for good reason. This day phase is very important.
|
|
|
|
Post by The Soul Of Philly on Oct 15, 2012 10:12:57 GMT -4
Finally, it took 3 bucks but I can get on the boards on my phone, which is why I've been severely quiet.
Alright here we go, I have this feeling the entire game that Arcadia is scum, specifically te hit man since she was so she was he'll bent on the idea of hit man. I've followed her the last two nights and got the result: Acadia is no where to be found, which leads me to believe that she's the hit man and that her tiff with Sally through off distraction vibes.
So Vote: Arcadia
Also I'm throwing a fos out
FoS: AC smith
Sally vehemently cleared him as town the minute suspicion was cast on him. I believe him to be town but just the way Sally acted makes me second think it. I don't have a split count ATM, but I'm town through and through, lynching me is a mistake.
|
|
|
|
Post by The Soul Of Philly on Oct 15, 2012 10:16:45 GMT -4
The split is 3/1/1 which means we need to get scum this day phase and Watson the next day phase.
|
|
|
|
Post by A.C. Smith on Oct 15, 2012 10:25:56 GMT -4
Also I'm throwing a fos out FoS: AC smith Sally vehemently cleared him as town the minute suspicion was cast on him. I believe him to be town but just the way Sally acted makes me second think it. I don't have a split count ATM, but I'm town through and through, lynching me is a mistake. Wrong, wrong, WRONG. I don't know how many times I have to repeat this, but apparently it's one more than it was before. After my night actions, rules regarding my role, and behavior have been hashed and rehashed over and over by many different people (L-1, JamesV, T-Marv, Sally, Rebel, and maybe one or two others), anyone thinking I'm anything but town is either scum or hasn't been paying attention. |
|
|
|
Post by Arcadia on Oct 15, 2012 10:26:58 GMT -4
Okay, TJ, you are really putting AC Smith under suspicion? How many times do we have to go over this? He's town, He's the doctor, and with how many confirmed townies have vouched for him it would have been suicide for Sally to do anything but the same. She's a very intelligent woman, so let's not jump to the "defend scum buddies" conclusion there. HE IS TOWN.
And TJ, you wouldn't have been able to find me with a night action. So long as my own night action is successful, I am untargettable. That doesn't make me scum, it makes me what I've said this whole time. A townie with an extremely self-serving role.
On that note...
Everyone is casting stones and pulling straws. Can we just finally go with the reliable thing and lynch Watson? I'm sorry Watson, but as much as you have helped town and pulled for town, you just aren't town and the game won't end with you alive.
Vote: Watson
|
|
|
|
Post by The Soul Of Philly on Oct 15, 2012 10:34:55 GMT -4
When did u ever say u had a self servin role? I do not recall u ever saying that, if you can provide proof of such statement ill drop the vote. The suspicion thing is just my thinking I'm throwing it out there Because that's my line of thinking and it's close to the end I feel as all opinions and line of thinking should be known
|
|
|
|
Post by T-Marv on Oct 15, 2012 10:52:25 GMT -4
Vote Count:
TJ - 1(James V)
Arcadia - 1(TJ)
Watson - 1(Arcadia)
|
|
|
|
Post by Nick Watson on Oct 15, 2012 11:03:27 GMT -4
Excuse me if Im wrong...but didnt you say you had info on sally last day phase? Only to drop it for a rarhee unbelievable reason. Now you say you have a self serving role? Call me crazy but Im finding your explanation to be full of holes. Also voting me out now is a mistake. Especially if the last scum has a bomb like effect attached to it.
So gentlemen...I think we fiund the last scum. I will be the hammer just in case.
|
|
|
|
Post by Nick Watson on Oct 15, 2012 11:05:11 GMT -4
Posting from my phone sucks.
|
|
|
|
Post by Arcadia on Oct 15, 2012 11:26:28 GMT -4
Here: Again, I don't have any actual proof that I am town because my role is pretty self-focused. And Here: as I explained before my role is fairly self-serving. |
|
|
|
Post by Arcadia on Oct 15, 2012 11:31:00 GMT -4
I dropped it because I doubted myself. Turns out Sally was actually scum. Good for me and everyone else who believed me.
I have ALWAYS said my role is self serving. Why doesn't anyone pay attention? And the reason I think it's time to lynch you is because I think we have found all the scum.
I KNOW! Call me crazy right? I think Kristen Stewart was NOT recruited! I think she is a miller. or something like that. I think that Sally as the framer, set her up. I've never played with a framer, so I don't know exactly how it works. But that is my thought process. So yeah, I think its time to lynch you off and see if the game ends.
|
|
|
|
Post by A.C. Smith on Oct 15, 2012 11:37:45 GMT -4
Well, TJ and Arcadia certainly aren't making things easy on us. A few gut reactions:
- Putting an FOS on a PROVEN town player is a mistake. Doing so on a gut feeling when it's been proven time and time again that I'm town and serve a very beneficial town role is just plain dumb.
- Voting Watson out is a mistake. He should be our last lynch, and as such ensure that we win the game.
- Nick: Who were you saying had info on Sally and refused to come forward with it?
As an aside, here are the characters that, far as I can tell, are still alive in this game.
Miley Cyrus (town)
The Kardashians (town)
Kristen Stewart (mafia)
The Situation (third party)
We know Watson is Sitch. It should be thoroughly obvious (unless you're TJ) who I am, and we know that JamesV is town. Given the role structure, it's fair to say whoever JamesV can vouch for between Arcadia and TJ is also town. Given that he voted for TJ, I'm tempted to believe, despite some scum vibes thrown by the attempt to lynch Watson, that Arcadia is town.
I'll wait for JamesV to chime in with his thoughts before I go any further. But for now, my FOS is going nowhere.
|
|
|
|
Post by A.C. Smith on Oct 15, 2012 11:40:08 GMT -4
EBWOP
Arcadia posted while I was typing. There being a miller in this game may explain some stuff, but given that T-Marv said this game was going to be fairly straightforward, wouldn't that go against that concept? Granted, I'm not as experienced as others in this game, but that's my line of thinking at the moment. I still think that TJ, as the hammer, may indeed have been recruited, and may indeed have gone radio-silent yesterday once I announced my theory.
|
|
|
|
Post by The Soul Of Philly on Oct 15, 2012 11:42:26 GMT -4
So Arcadia did u not see the split? It's 3/1/1 which means there is still a scum member out there. Lynching nick is almost useless as there's no proof he can night kill, we need to find the last scum member or go down to 2 to one. Unless we can not find the last scum member, we do not kill Watson he's practically a town member atm
But i'm true to my word even though the second was taken from your post.
unvote arcadia
|
|
|
|
Post by Arcadia on Oct 15, 2012 12:15:00 GMT -4
Thank you for removing your vote. I saw how you split it. but 3/1/1 would support that Kristen Stewart's player was recruited, where my theory is that something happened that triggered the game to make them APPEAR scum though they are still town.
And yes, TMarv said he was running a fairly uncomplicated game, but let's be honest. We've got third parties, people's names changing colors left and right, Double night kills, multiple roleblockers, etc. So what is so hard to believe that there may be a miller or something like it? If my theory is correct and we lynch Watson, the game ends and we win.
|
|
|
|
Post by The Soul Of Philly on Oct 15, 2012 12:15:22 GMT -4
I've practically radio silent all game due to not login in on my phone properly
|
|
|
|
Post by The Soul Of Philly on Oct 15, 2012 13:24:50 GMT -4
Thank you for removing your vote. I saw how you split it. but 3/1/1 would support that Kristen Stewart's player was recruited, where my theory is that something happened that triggered the game to make them APPEAR scum though they are still town. And yes, TMarv said he was running a fairly uncomplicated game, but let's be honest. We've got third parties, people's names changing colors left and right, Double night kills, multiple roleblockers, etc. So what is so hard to believe that there may be a miller or something like it? If my theory is correct and we lynch Watson, the game ends and we win. Your theory is wrong. There is nothin that would make cause a switch in a right up. A town miller comes up town in the write ups, would only appear scum when investigate. An seeing how no one on the mafia had anything to do with Stewart in real life a reactionary action that would change we alignment is unlikely, leading to the recruitment theory being the one. IMO the only pros of lynching Watson it would not be a mislynch on a townie giving us another night to use out powers and hope that whoever comes out of that night phase has something |
|
|
|
Post by The Soul Of Philly on Oct 15, 2012 13:41:27 GMT -4
AC u forgot sea crest
|
|
|
|
Post by The Soul Of Philly on Oct 15, 2012 13:45:07 GMT -4
Vote: Arcadia
I'm sorry looking over the character in the wrote ups and the following information each night, who was roleblocked followed who etc, I know who I am, I think i know who James is, it's obvious who AC and Watson is. That leaves Arcadia. And if not I'm completely wrong on James, but I'm betting I'm not.
I'm not letting you talk ur way out it. I got you
|
|
|
|
Post by A.C. Smith on Oct 15, 2012 13:48:01 GMT -4
And yes, TMarv said he was running a fairly uncomplicated game, but let's be honest. We've got third parties, people's names changing colors left and right, Double night kills, multiple roleblockers, etc. So what is so hard to believe that there may be a miller or something like it? If my theory is correct and we lynch Watson, the game ends and we win. I don't want to come across too harsh here (L-1 I'm not!  ), but that's VERY easy for you to say when, if we lynch Watson, you're 99% not the target for the mafia's kill (assuming they still can). The sequence would likely go thusly. - Lynch Watson. - Kill A.C. or JamesV, one of the two known townies (again, assuming the mafia can still kill), and hope neither is protected by a doctor. - TJ, Arcadia, and A.C./JamesV are left, assuming the kill goes through. TJ votes Arcadia. Arcadia votes TJ. And that leaves whatever remaining townie is left to make the biggest decision in the game, one that determines who wins and who loses. To be honest, that's not a scenario that sits well with me. Again, as of now, I will not vote until JamesV posts again with his thoughts on my previous theory (outlined in the post I made about two hours ago). |
|
|
|
Post by Arcadia on Oct 15, 2012 14:18:58 GMT -4
TJ, I haven't tried to talk my way out of anything. I cannot character claim. But that shouldn't stop you from figuring it out on your own. Now that you have, it should make even more sense to you that I'm right. You may think I'm trying to cover my tracks, and I understand if you do, but hear me out.
I used my night action on Sally the night before someone was supposedly "recruited" to the mafia. Based on that night action and the results that I got from it I went after Sally as scum. Sally turned out to be a framer. How strange that I used my night action on the framer and suddenly a name changes colors. Because you know, if someone was being framed, that is totally what would happen. Lynch me if you must, but once it comes out that I am town, you should know you have to kill Watson because there ARENT ANY MAFIA LEFT!!
|
|
|
|
Post by The Soul Of Philly on Oct 15, 2012 14:42:10 GMT -4
To me it doesn't add up. Okay I think we really need to look at Sally. Here are my reasons: She played very aggressively the first two days. One day ended in a third party lynch, the other in a townie lynch. As soon as we have a scum lynch, not only does her play style do a 180, but she doesn't vote. She also said that her style this game has been to be "dead" during day phases, which is ironic considering how she pushed lynches both days, or rather, assisted in a lynch push on day one and led a lynch on day two. Level-One stayed alive for WAAAAAY too long playing so aggressively and obviously pro-town for me to think that its a coincidence that the night after he points a finger at Sally he ends up dead. I think she kept him around while he was looking at others but now that he finally nailed scum it was time to let him fry. He was easy to hide behind pushing lynches because of how aggressive he played. She tried to detract attention from the lynch on Knuckles and push a third party lynch on Wason. And lastly, I used my role on her last night, and got different results than I have ever before. Let me state now that I DO NOT HAVE 100% PROOF Sally is scum. I just got sketchy results. But all of that together is enough for me. You have a self serving power that allows you to target people, contradictory power, but ok. you used it on Sally and got something different than the previous targets first question: who did you target the previous nights? Next bit you say the say the night u visited her the person I believe you to be magically showed up red, claiming she must have used her power on you which means your person showed up red. In games with a framer I've never seen the persons name change, in simpson mafia, blade frames cj almost every night and never did mr burns come up red, he stayed purple. Had he been investigated, he would turn up scum, but Now it's tmarvs right ups and he may do something differently but I don't know. So I have to take what I see and I see ur person red and that means ur a scum. If we lynch you and u are town as you claim, it sets back the win by a day phase Also for information I followed mania who visited Jules,Watson who visited no one, James the night he blocked knuckles, and Arcadia the last two nights. |
|
|
|
Post by Nick Watson on Oct 15, 2012 14:47:15 GMT -4
Smith: I thought you were the doctor?
Arcadia: I'm not buying it.
I know it's hard for you to come to grips with it, but in some iterations the God Father has the ability to recruit people into the fold as Mafia. This may be such a game as it is something new to add in for us all to enjoy. Kirsten Stewart started out as a member of the town, but was recruited as a one time power by the God Father. Also originally you stuck up for the God Father the night before Level One had been lynched.
You even went as far as lashing out at the known town of James V who has done nothing, but help us move further, and further forward. No...nope...not happening. I'm not allowing you to smooth talk me even if it costs me my visitation rights to my God damn goat. I'm taking a stand here and throwing it out there!
Arcadia is scum. I pointed this out earlier today because I believed it. Her role does not exist within the town...there exists no role that has both bulletproof and of course investigation powers.
Her line of thinking was to confuse us by trying to cover up her trail. She had been recruited the night before by the Godfather...that is why there has been no recruitment after that.
The fact is...she has given nothing to us at all in the form of hard evidence. The fact that she says her power is only good for her, but yet can investigate, and give info makes me believe she is full of crap. So, do whatever you guys want, but I'm going to vote: Arcadia.
I would like to add this before we move on to the next game...you guys did a heck of a job Arcadia. You would have gotten away with it if Sally had gotten what she had wanted...lynching me. The mafia has tried to use me as a sure fire bet lynch for a while now. Trying to get me out of the game before I could catch on to something big.
I was a sure fire town vote. They knew that and along with that same line of thinking understood that when it came down to the last days that this would happen. So...nice try, better luck next time!
|
|
|
|
Post by A.C. Smith on Oct 15, 2012 15:07:54 GMT -4
OK, so apparently I forgot Ryan Seacrest in the character lineup (thanks, TJ). That changes things for me.
In looking at the game, I always thought the Kardashians were a group of people within the game, a mason group of sorts. In truth, it's one player controlling all of them, which is a little strange yet explains a lot.
Unfortunately, what that means is that JamesV doesn't have the answer I'm looking for. Which BITES, and means I've got a good deal of thinking to do since I'm the one person who hasn't cast a vote yet.
|
|
|
|
Post by Arcadia on Oct 15, 2012 15:13:50 GMT -4
I'm town, and I will come up town when I die. So. Keep in mind after tonight that my death means there are no mafia left and its just time to lynch Watson.
Love you guys!
Vote: Arcadia
|
|
), but that's VERY easy for you to say when, if we lynch Watson, you're 99% not the target for the mafia's kill (assuming they still can). The sequence would likely go thusly.
