Game of Thrones Mafia - Day 3 (17 Alive)

[Buckson Gooch]

Apr 15, 2013 10:56:26 GMT -4 Talon said:

Instead of just voting for no reason and then getting us to another night phase without any info, I'm going to talk before I cast a vote.

Franchise thought it was either Callahan, Me, or Gates... Callahan came up scum, and I've not been counter claimed, so GOOCH, you should know that I'm town dude.

What do you guys think about Callahan claiming Speede is no good? Most likely just mafia trying to mindfuck everyone yeah?

If Speede is just being thrown out there by Callahan to cause doubt, it really only leaves Gates as potential scum, so he gets my vote this phase.

Vote: Gates

Talon, We've been paired up in games before. You've been known to false claim roles before. I guess what I don't know is what roles were given out to those who weren't aligned at all in the beginning and then got roles. But if that's all I've got...you could turn around and blast some of the dumb stuff I've done in Mafia games or things I've done to save my hide If you tell any of it, I'll vote for you again, hahaha.

To that end, I may be a big dummy, but I believe you.

Unvote

I'm not ready to jump on the Gates vote, tho.

[Matt Stone]

Without a write-up, this is kind if frustrating, but I think we only have Stannis and the red witch left, so no more "scum".

I don't see what throwing Speede under the bus has to do with anything as far as red goes, so maybe he was just outing another anti-town role, sort of an "enemy of my enemy" scenario so I think I'm going to go with that.

Vote: Speede

[Talon]

Stone, good read possibly, I've had a rough time getting into this game 100% so the faction aspect keeps screwing me up, I'd be willing to go that route if the rest of the town thinks its the best play.

My vote is only on Gates because of James' posts.

[Matt Stone]

James post last day phase said his clear of Speede could be false. Just pointing that out.

[Talon]

Yep, noted that myself.

[C.J. Gates]

Voting for me won't help us eliminate Stannis or the other third party, because I'm town. I don't know if there's anything I could say to convince everyone of that, but I assure you that I am not third party aligned.

As for who could be, I'm not sure. Part of me thinks that one of the third party members might be hiding in the confirmed town, while another part of me doesn't totally buy Talon's claim. Not because it's not possible, but because I'm trying to think of what character in the show could be his role. Which is also why I'm not placing a vote on him yet.

[Talon]

I guess it would be hard to figure out who could save someone from being hanged in a game featuring kings and queens and all that jazz.

Then again, I have zero flavor knowledge.

[Matt Stone]

I think at this point, we should consider role claiming and getting that sorted out. I have re-read everything and I think we have two protective roles left.

I am one of them.

Talon has soft claimed Governor already, and Gates has admitted to using his role as well.

From what I have seen, Speede nor Kyle have hinted at what they do/have been doing.

[Speede]

Checking in. Seeing James dead is quite disheartening as he was the one who lead us in the last couple of scum lynches. What makes me question this, though, is that he was the one who was able to get us the information we had...

Stone, why on earth, if you had a protective role, were you not protecting the guy who has been able to provide us with information for who is and is not town?

My theory on the above is that you're lying, and you're one of the remaining anti-town players trying to throw us off track with a vote on me. Look at the cold hard facts, bro.

-Callahan was trying to say I'm not town, when he flipped red scum. There's no motivation for him to help the town, and that was all a plot to try to cause confusion and try to keep the town from getting the victory we all know is approaching if we stay on track. JamesV, the guy who's been able to tell so far who is and is not town was targeted for a nightkill last night, and the one guy claiming a protective role wasn't there to stop the kill. Pretty suspicious IMO, and I'm starting to question whether you're clear or not, Stone.

We've got six people left, and of those six, we've got our targets: Talon and Gates; if it weren't for JamesV's list, I'd be after you, but Stone, all we've got to do is get rid of these two and the game's over.

Vote: Talon

[Talon]

Unvote

vote: Speede

Not an OMGUS vote but your response is far less town-ish than Gates was.

[Matt Stone]

Why wasn't I protecting James? He outed himself as useless. It was obvious as soon as he said your clear wasn't 100% that he only had info on recruited members. I was doing the smart thing and protecting myself. I know the flavor and it screamed Littlefinger to me. The rules are the only thing keeping me from outting everyone.

I know who the 6 remaining characters are.

Until you come fourth with what your role is, you are getting voted by me.

[T-Marv]

Vote Count:

Speede - 3 (Talon, Matt Stone)
Talon - 1 (Speede)

[Speede]

Apr 15, 2013 19:30:09 GMT -4 Matt Stone said:

Why wasn't I protecting James? He outed himself as useless. It was obvious as soon as he said your clear wasn't 100% that he only had info on recruited members. I was doing the smart thing and protecting myself. I know the flavor and it screamed Littlefinger to me. The rules are the only thing keeping me from outting everyone.

I know who the 6 remaining characters are.

Until you come fourth with what your role is, you are getting voted by me.

Okay, I can't character claim since that's breaking the rules, but I've had a couple different one-shot actions. Among them I've gotten a couple of interesting pieces of data, and that includes that I can confirm Buckson Gooch is clear, and that Talon is 100% anti-town. I was hoping I could hold onto this so I didn't get myself targeted by a nightkill, but I've used up all my one-shots as of last night so it's not as if it matters now. We can get Talon here, and then it's between Kyle and Gates as to who our last target is.

Also, T-Marv, your vote count should say two, not three.

[Talon]

Well since you're pretending to spill the beans on me being "100%" anti town, why not give some details on what you say you know about me, because I'd love to hear what you come up with.

[Speede]

Apr 15, 2013 20:37:42 GMT -4 Talon said:

Well since you're pretending to spill the beans on me being "100%" anti town, why not give some details on what you say you know about me, because I'd love to hear what you come up with.

Fine, you want to know everything I know about you, Talon? You're Stannis Baratheon, the one in charge of the purple third party, and among your night actions so far include the night one recruiting of Crown Jules as your minion; he was subsequently returned to the town side by JamesV later in the game. And I also know that you're able to send out night kills, except night one when you recruited Jules.

So far you've killed off Havok, Crown Jules (after finding out he was un-recruited, in an attempt to make sure he didn't out you), Billy Pepsi, and most recently JamesV, with the assumption that without him we would fall as a town.

[Talon]

LOL alright, so thanks for completely confirming for me that Gate's isn't the anti-town and you are the right vote.

I'm the reason you have that second vote on you man, I can single shot pardon a lynch and all my votes (since being moved from unaligned to seven kingdoms after the first night) are double votes. Don't believe it? Go check the vote counts when I was second to last and hammered and a few others.

[Kurt]

Apr 15, 2013 17:35:21 GMT -4 Matt Stone said:

I think at this point, we should consider role claiming and getting that sorted out. I have re-read everything and I think we have two protective roles left.

I am one of them.

Talon has soft claimed Governor already, and Gates has admitted to using his role as well.

From what I have seen, Speede nor Kyle have hinted at what they do/have been doing.

Ask, and you shall receive.

I'm an item-giver; I have been giving items since night 2 (was vanilla night 1). I've given items to Havok (night 2 - I admit on day 3 to visiting him), JamesV (night 3), Pepsi (Night 4), JamesV (night 5), JamesV (night 6), and last night...to Speede.

So, there's only one person left who can validate that I've been doing who can back up my claim.

I just got in from work, so I need a bit of time to read back through all this; I'll have a vote in the morning, assuming it hasn't already happened.

[C.J. Gates]

Well, like Talon said, I think it's safe to assume that Speede is the right vote. There's no way he'd be able to pinpoint exactly who was killed without write ups without having done them himself.

Vote: Speede

[T-Marv]

My vote count was right. Gate's lynch is four

Matt Stone, Talon, CJ Gates.... That's four.

LYNCH!!!!

DEAD - Roy Speede - The Red Lady(don't remember her name) - Baratheon Aligned

Night is now.... 24 hours.

[T-Marv]

DEAD - Matt Stone - Brianne - Bodyguard

Alive:
1. CJ Gates
2. Talon Wilkinson
3. Buckson Gooch
4. Kyle

Takes 3 to lynch.

48 hours... GO!

[Talon]

well damn it, Stone was the only person I was really confident in, I thought I'd die for outing myself... Mafia, you kinda dumb bro?

[Talon]

EBWOP: Mafia, 3rd party, whatever the hell is left at this point.

[Talon]

I'm going to Vote: Kyle

He said Speede could clear him, and didnt vote for him, so its more than I have to go by with Gates, and I'm confident Gooch is town.

[Buckson Gooch]

I feel pretty confident that Matt Stone was protecting me last night and ended up getting killed. I was a confirmed townie from early in the game...but I could be wrong. I strongly believe that Talon is town, I have my doubts about Gates, but I can go with Kyle. His role could easily be 3rd party.

Vote: Kyle

[T-Marv]

THat's a lynch.

DEAD - Kyle - Gendry - Blacksmith(RoleGiver)

Night starts now.

[T-Marv]

THERE WAS NO KILL LAST NIGHT

Alive.:

Talon
Gates
Gooch

With 3 alive it takes 2 votes to lynch.

[Talon]

Vote: Gates

If I'm wrong, Im sorry, and gooch gets major points from me, but that's what I'm goin for.

[Buckson Gooch]

I used my night action on gates and there's no kill that's good enough for me.

vote: gates

[T-Marv]

THATS A LYNCH! Writeup Coming soon!

[T-Marv]

DEAD - CJ Gates - Robert Baratheon - 3rd party Godfather

TOWN WINS! TOWN WINS! BA GAWD THE TOWN WINS

Alive winners.... Gooch and Talon!

Fallout thread in the morning