Game of Thrones Mafia - Day 3 (17 Alive)

[T-Marv]

VOTE COUNT:

TJ - 2 (Shields, Mania)

17alive/9 to lynch

Deadline 12:00 noon EDT Tomorrow

[Chris Shields]

Mar 25, 2013 15:12:31 GMT -4 Speede said:

I'm not going to jump on that right away, Chris. you're "guarantee"ing it? How sure are you?

100% sure about this. If I'm wrong about this, I'll be the first one to vote for my lynch tomorrow.

[Speede]

Okay, if you're 100%, I'll go for it.
Vote: TJ

[C.J. Gates]

Mar 25, 2013 15:29:38 GMT -4 Chris Shields said:

Mar 25, 2013 15:12:31 GMT -4 Speede said:

I'm not going to jump on that right away, Chris. you're "guarantee"ing it? How sure are you?

100% sure about this. If I'm wrong about this, I'll be the first one to vote for my lynch tomorrow.

I'm assuming it's from something you got at night? If that's the case, and you are 100% sure that he is anti-town then I am going to trust your information.

Vote: TJ

[T-Marv]

VOTE COUNT:

TJ - 4 (Shields, Mania, Speede, Gates)

17alive/9 to lynch

Deadline 12:00 noon EDT Tomorrow

[Jules]

Just got in after a long day travelling. I'll jump in here when I've had something to eat and a chance to go over the thread thoroughly.

[Michael Jennings]

Mar 25, 2013 14:55:25 GMT -4 Chris Shields said:

Vote: TJ, He is not town and I can guarantee that. Trust me on this and we'll get rid of an anti-town player.

Vote: TJ

I trust Chris on this one. His latest post has me certain on this.

[Mark Mania]

Just some words for thought here. You're telling me Pepsi replies to me three or four times in under five minutes but then when TJ is getting voted for he's MIA? Sounds like someone is checking in with his QT.

[Pepsi]

Mar 25, 2013 15:17:43 GMT -4 Mark Mania said:

Unvote: Pepsi
Vote: TJ

Kind of had the feeling. My vote for Pepsi is certainly not a joke, he claims that he's joking around and being all tongue in cheek, but he was defensive of Stone and TJ, now TJ is being confirmed as not town, wouldn't be surprised if it was all three of them.

I don't do anything without a reason. So Pepsi, James, and Speede can call it stupid play, I see it as Pepsi outing himself in trying to be the bigger man and trying to make me look a fool. Not today good sirs.

Not trying to make you look like a fool Mark.

My post was not in defense of TJ, I was simply saying I was not willing to base a vote off someone lobbying hard for a vote on Knuckles as that logic would put me, and several others in the crossfire.

Yes I defended Stone for reasons I stated in my previous post and will not reiterate here.

My comment about you being immature was in fact a joke just as it was a joke when I mocked Knuckles on day 1, believe what you want to believe concerning that.

As for TJ, I will take Chris' word on this as he has given no reason for me to not believe he is being truthful.

Vote: TJ

[T-Marv]

VOTE COUNT:

TJ - 5 (Shields, Mania, Speede, Gates, James V)

17alive/9 to lynch

Deadline 12:00 noon EDT Tomorrow

[The Soul Of Philly]

God forbid someone who works outside all day doesn't have the time to respond to getting votes on him.

Ill have more when I get home in a hour or so. I will say this I get 80/20 on knuckles, his play turned it too 100.

[The Soul Of Philly]

EBWOP.

Also any rushing to lynch me, ATM I have 5 need 9, are scummy an should be looked into. I'm only asking until I get home from work to defend myself.

[Buckson Gooch]

I can respect that, TJ.

Unvote

[T-Marv]

I apologize for missing you on the TJ vote Gooch... That was the ONLY vote count mistake made.

[Pepsi]

Mar 25, 2013 15:48:38 GMT -4 Mark Mania said:

Just some words for thought here. You're telling me Pepsi replies to me three or four times in under five minutes but then when TJ is getting voted for he's MIA? Sounds like someone is checking in with his QT.

Missed this post before. If by checking in with QT you mean playing outside with my daughters you are absolutely right.

Btw my vote clearly doesn't count anyways this day phase. I'm sure Mark will find this fishy too.

[Speede]

Mar 25, 2013 16:16:38 GMT -4 Pepsi said:

Mar 25, 2013 15:48:38 GMT -4 Mark Mania said:

Just some words for thought here. You're telling me Pepsi replies to me three or four times in under five minutes but then when TJ is getting voted for he's MIA? Sounds like someone is checking in with his QT.

Missed this post before. If by checking in with QT you mean playing outside with my daughters you are absolutely right.

Btw my vote clearly doesn't count anyways this day phase. I'm sure Mark will find this fishy too.

Any explanation why that is, Pepsi?

[Pepsi]

Mar 25, 2013 16:19:28 GMT -4 Speede said:

Mar 25, 2013 16:16:38 GMT -4 Pepsi said:

Missed this post before. If by checking in with QT you mean playing outside with my daughters you are absolutely right.

Btw my vote clearly doesn't count anyways this day phase. I'm sure Mark will find this fishy too.

Any explanation why that is, Pepsi?

Same thing happened to James V last day phase. My guess is someone has the ability to take away a vote and used it on me. Which means I was both Roleblocked and had my vote taken from me.

[C.J. Gates]

Mar 25, 2013 15:55:06 GMT -4 The Soul Of Philly said:

God forbid someone who works outside all day doesn't have the time to respond to getting votes on him.

Ill have more when I get home in a hour or so. I will say this I get 80/20 on knuckles, his play turned it too 100.

You said you were 80/20 on Knuckles, then after his play you said he was 100% and then he turned up town.

Now we hear from Chris that you're 100% anti-town.

Am I missing something?

[Matt Stone]

We gain nothing from lynching TJ today rather than tomorrow, so giving him time seems like a good idea, though Chris says he's 100% and maybe he doesn't want to be targeted too hard at the night phase so he's not straight out role claiming, which is smart. I have a "power role" so I should be easy to clear by anyone.

[Chris Shields]

Mar 25, 2013 16:40:26 GMT -4 Matt Stone said:

We gain nothing from lynching TJ today rather than tomorrow, so giving him time seems like a good idea, though Chris says he's 100% and maybe he doesn't want to be targeted too hard at the night phase so he's not straight out role claiming, which is smart. I have a "power role" so I should be easy to clear by anyone.

We gain 1 less anti town player. Unless someone knows that a particular player is red mafia, why not go ahead and get rid of an anti town player? I'm in favor of waiting for more information, but if we don't have anything else that's concrete then we lynch TJ and help ourselves out a little more by narrowing down the list of suspects.

[Pepsi]

Mar 25, 2013 16:45:03 GMT -4 Chris Shields said:

Mar 25, 2013 16:40:26 GMT -4 Matt Stone said:

We gain nothing from lynching TJ today rather than tomorrow, so giving him time seems like a good idea, though Chris says he's 100% and maybe he doesn't want to be targeted too hard at the night phase so he's not straight out role claiming, which is smart. I have a "power role" so I should be easy to clear by anyone.

We gain 1 less anti town player. Unless someone knows that a particular player is red mafia, why not go ahead and get rid of an anti town player? I'm in favor of waiting for more information, but if we don't have anything else that's concrete then we lynch TJ and help ourselves out a little more by narrowing down the list of suspects.

^^^^

This 100%.

The town needs to eliminate all threats. I agree that unless someone has some better info it's pointless to delay.

Chris has put himself heavily on the line with this guarantee. I for one am willing to accept it, but alas my vote means nothing and according to Mark I'm working with TJ so take my thoughts for what they are worth to you.

[Kurt]

Super quick post before I head to work.

I just wanna out that I did visit Havok last night, just in case anyone targeted me/him and saw; don't wanna have to look bad with that later, you know?

I'll have more later.

[Matt Stone]

xD Apparently people are confused. Chris, I meant lynching him on Monday means the same as lynching him on Tuesday. I didn't mean the next day phase.

[The Soul Of Philly]

Ok, who ever is fucking with me needs ot stop. This is the third time I posted this.

Yes, I was 80/20 on Knuckles. I used a one shot role block on Knuckles based on his first day of play. I know during the last game, I thought about bringing up silencing on teh first day, figured it be a bad play. During the night, we had nothing from the taragarian's and I figured that was partly due to me. I put the vote down and then when Knuckles reacted the way he did, I felt more confident, 100% sure that he was scum, especially when he said that he did what he did to get himself checked, yet he shapeshifted into James.

I have three one shot actions a roleblock, a watch and a track, but it came with a consequence. After I use one of them, I am turned into a vanilla miller. Therefore if you tracked me Chris, you were misdirected info back to you because I did not go anywhere. If you copped me, you were got a false reading. I am town, apparently, I am among the few that started as town.

What bothers me the most about this is that Chris lays down a vote and immediately I have 5 or six votes on me all buying Chris's guarantee. THAT NEVER FLIES IN MAFIA! Especially from someone who isn't cleared as town. Given that there are so many factions, I count 7 anti-town characters, i'm willing to bet that most of them are scum, jumping on a mislynch of a townie because they know it's not one of their own.

There, my chips are on teh table. If I'm lynched, you guys know who to look at.

As far as the night actions goes, it looks like we went from 11/8 to 10/7 which I feel is alright number wise, but what sucks is we lost our tracker and cop. Given my role, I'm thinking that there are some of us who have those powers with a twist.

[Level-Two]

Vote: TJ

I have biding my time and I wanted to give him an opportunity to plead his case because of what happened with Knuckles but given his response in comparison with Chris Shields guarantee, I'm short of a certain that TJ is the right lynch and will flip in either of the three anti town factions.

I could start by picking away at TJ's claim but I won't bother to do so unless this day stalls out.

[C.J. Gates]

For now I'm going to

Unvote: TJ

For no reason other than to hear more of what he's saying. If I understand right you had the choice of those three roles and once you used one, you became a vanilla miller...curiously. It might be my inexperience in games of this magnitude and games with role variances, but if someone is vanilla, they usually don't have anything else to them, do they? So if you're a vanilla miller wouldn't you just be a miller?

[Level-Two]

Mar 25, 2013 18:33:25 GMT -4 C.J. Gates said:

For now I'm going to

Unvote: TJ

For no reason other than to hear more of what he's saying. If I understand right you had the choice of those three roles and once you used one, you became a vanilla miller...curiously. It might be my inexperience in games of this magnitude and games with role variances, but if someone is vanilla, they usually don't have anything else to them, do they? So if you're a vanilla miller wouldn't you just be a miller?

For starters...

If your town and had those three powers you wouldn't use it knowing that you'd be turned into a miller.

Now because I have pointed this out... TJ will now claim that he didn't know what the consequence was.

I have three one shot actions a roleblock, a watch and a track, but it came with a consequence. After I use one of them, I am turned into a vanilla miller.

Unfortunately, this statement reads like he was aware he'd be turned into a miller.

Furthermore, if this is my role not only would I NOT use one of these three powers but even if I didn't - it wouldn't be to role block someone whom I thought was suspicions (knuckles) - I'd track them.

Doing anything else is a noob mistake and I doubt that is the case with TJ.

I could go into even MORE if we'd like to play this game. TJ made a safe claim, a weak one at that.

The more I start to write - the more I certain I actually become about the result.

[KJE]

TJ said what he had to say... Im still not convinced. Im sorry, you said you were sure about knucks, then he turned up town... someone is saying you're anti town and are putting themselves at stake if they are wrong, but they say they are 100 about it... imma have to get rid of Anti town.

Vote :TJ

[papapancho]

Vote TJ

There's also the chance he straight out is lying.

[Michael Jennings]

Mar 25, 2013 21:10:03 GMT -4 papapancho said:

Vote TJ

There's also the chance he straight out is lying.

This. Which is why my vote is staying right where it is.