GFX Feedback

[Kevin Dahlia]

apwprez.proboards.com/index.cgi?board=artgalery&action=display&thread=10376

Just looking for some feedback on some old sigs I made, haha. Thanks

[Young Kiz]

yep i noticed them, pretty bad dude... nice shit forreal imo. you think you could make me one?

[Kevin Dahlia]

Honestly, I'd love to man, but sadly, I can't. That was all made on my old laptop, with CS5. I currently am running a Linux Ubunut-GNOME, and it doesn't allow me to install most things Windows/Mac based, even while running the WINE terminal. If I somehow get CS5, I will be more than happy to make you one though ^_^

My own sig was made by my friend, haha.

[The Soul Of Philly]

I love the Jimmy Jacobs one but they're all good.

[[ManiC]]

Hey! I made you the Jimmy Rave Josh Majesty GIF one

But seriously, never knew you progressed this much in GFX; very impressed. I remember giving you the tutorial for the last one.

[Blade]

I am not going to be the nicest critique, but I will be honest and constructive.. Dont take it personally...

Feedback


Post Hardcore -

Not really a fan. It kind of looks like 3 separate images that have been thrown together. I can see what you went for but to me the two pictures on the outside stand out too much because the blending into the background picture is pretty poor. Good Idea, Not overly executed.

Oh, and I see it re occurring, but I really dont like the dashed border its too distracting from the image itself. A 2px black border will work fine.

Get the blending right along with maybe a similar colour balance running through the image and you have a winner.


Josh Majesty -

Again, bad choice of pics. Try never to use pictures with ropes in because unless they match up well. Too many contrasting pictures and the image looks crowded.

Border (see above)

Maybe use a drop shadow instead of an outerglow for Sabin.


Randy fields -

Pixel font. Outer glow. Choice of pics and blending. Choice of filter running over pics (se above for all)


Josh Majesty -

Great skill to put a .GIF in an image, kudos for that. The image works well however, I wouldnt have used the image on the right and would have stuck with the image on the left, shortening the width of the GFX overall.

Border - See above


Kyle Penthlock? -

Text is kind of hard to read.

Border (see above)

Too much overcrowding and wrong choice of images that dont work together.

text - The Pixel fone doesnt really work here.



AGAIN, I AM NOT BASHING THESE, SO DO NOT TAKE OFFENCE


I have highlighted the negative points more because I think those are things that need work. if I highlighted the things you can do well you would not learn.

Take time in choosing the right pictures and testing to see if they actually fit together, some times less is more.

Also try to work on the blending if you do use alot of pictures, google some tutorials there are plenty out there.


Plenty of potential here, just some fine tuning.

Keep it up