MUPPETS MAFIA GAME THREAD (Day Seven - Six people)

[Reaver]

he HASNT poked holes in anything, its HIM that has all the info against him not me. all thats against me is terry's supposed nite info which i call bs on while reya has said that he was statler, rebel said he WASNT role blocked nite 1 and rex watched him do something and laid down the vote. how convenient that rex isnt around for terry to fight against. terry is anti-town and somehow weaseled his way into lynching not just 1 townie but 2. u guys do wat u want but his metagaming is getting old.

[T-Marv]

Jan 13, 2014 12:02:58 GMT -4 Reaver said:

he HASNT poked holes in anything, its HIM that has all the info against him not me. all thats against me is terry's supposed nite info which i call bs on while reya has said that he was statler, rebel said he WASNT role blocked nite 1 and rex watched him do something and laid down the vote. how convenient that rex isnt around for terry to fight against. terry is anti-town and somehow weaseled his way into lynching not just 1 townie but 2. u guys do wat u want but his metagaming is getting old.

Reya said Statler is likely either Rebel or me and is now leaning more towards Rebel.
Rebel said he didn't believe I was roleblocked, but gave no firm evidence.
Rex voted for me and that's it. He couldn't have used his night action on night cause he was a REPLACEMENT night one.


Enough holes for you?

Fact of the matter. I made a bet you won't take cause you know that i'm town... cause you're scum.

You don't like my metagaming? QUIT! I'm doing whatever it takes for the town to win... DEAL WITH IT!

[Reaver]

ur doing watever it takes for u to stay alive long enuff to kill townies off n win. ur pushing the wrong lynch terry and u no it. ur gonna get 2 townies killed. if u think a cash bet is wats gonna save u then ur wrong. i may b dead but u WILL b caught

[Reaver]

ebwop, wat will u do next after i come up town and a second town is killed with me?

[T-Marv]

Jan 13, 2014 12:10:44 GMT -4 Reaver said:

ur doing watever it takes for u to stay alive long enuff to kill townies off n win. ur pushing the wrong lynch terry and u no it. ur gonna get 2 townies killed. if u think a cash bet is wats gonna save u then ur wrong. i may b dead but u WILL b caught

I already said if the town thinks a lynch on me is best then to DO it... it will provide information as well and show me to be telling the truth.

Something you are UNABLE to do cause YOU are the one desperately trying to stay alive, as CJ said throwing shit against a wall expecting it to stick.

[T-Marv]

Jan 13, 2014 12:11:27 GMT -4 Reaver said:

ebwop, wat will u do next after i come up town and a second town is killed with me?

I won't have to worry about that, cause you are for sure scum.

IF you come up town... I'm dead regardless... but I don't have to worry about that.

[Reaver]

dont need to terry the proof ive been spitting has been true. not to mention the fact that u keep bringing up how rex was a replacement even tho he has a nite 1 action and posted it on day 2. it was nite 2 he was killed so replacement or no, he still watched u and voted for u for the same reasons explained. either accept it or not but after i come up green and the town loses 2, u will b gone.

[T-Marv]

Jan 13, 2014 12:16:29 GMT -4 Reaver said:

dont need to terry the proof ive been spitting has been true. not to mention the fact that u keep bringing up how rex was a replacement even tho he has a nite 1 action and posted it on day 2. it was nite 2 he was killed so replacement or no, he still watched u and voted for u for the same reasons explained. either accept it or not but after i come up green and the town loses 2, u will b gone.

Rex said nothing of the sort. He didn't post on day 2 that he had a night action. He simply voted.
He was a replacement day 2... how could he have a night 1 action?

rules read:

14. I expect you to be active. The game will not survive without activity, so get stuck in. If you know you'll be away from a computer for a certain period of time and may miss a day or night period, just let me know via PM, and as long as you post when you can, no problem. If you are inactive for a full day phase without notifying me of real-life reasons, I will prod you. If you have a night action and do not submit it by the deadline after being prodded, you will be mod-killed. If you don't have a night action, you have until the night period is over to get back to me, otherwise you will be mod-killed.

So what happened was, The guy he replaced didn't respond to the prod with his night action by deadline. So Tritch replaced him.

Deadline is over.

You're telling me that AFTER all that, AC Smith allowed Tritch to get a night action?

You can SAY whatever you want, but what I've presented are facts.

[T-Marv]

People We should be looking at the next night and day:

Stefan Raab... He's posted a couple times, but has offered nothing and seems to be stalling on the Knuckles Lynch

The Last King / Justinp - If neither of these guys is modkilled, then we need to seriously wonder if they're being silenced, or just scum who didn't post during the day but used their night action to stay alive.

Rebel... Also stalling and based on Reya's info, likely Statler.

Bryan Deas - It could be his normal play, or he could be doing something fishy with the double vote on me.

Likely one person on the Knuckles Lynch is Scum trying to play it off. We need to be careful there as well.

[Lord Raab]

What else can I offer other than what I've said about using my night action on Terry which was successful? I'm finding all the arguments on here confusing as hell and I don't understand them at all. I've already stated that I'm not a roleblocker but I'm not going to vote for someone if I can't understand the posts on here. Maybe I need to read through the posts again to understand these arguments and who to vote for.

[Lord Raab]

EBTWOP: OK since I read through the latest posts and I don't buy anything that Knuckles is saying at all, especially with the lovers role he claimed cos he has way too much info in this game which the role I had before in the mafia game and that in my view is complete rubbish and not to mention how confusing he's making the game with this game. So therefore I'm going to make my vote now.

Vote: Reaver

[Reaver]

Jan 13, 2014 12:24:35 GMT -4 T-Marv said:

Jan 13, 2014 12:16:29 GMT -4 Reaver said:

dont need to terry the proof ive been spitting has been true. not to mention the fact that u keep bringing up how rex was a replacement even tho he has a nite 1 action and posted it on day 2. it was nite 2 he was killed so replacement or no, he still watched u and voted for u for the same reasons explained. either accept it or not but after i come up green and the town loses 2, u will b gone.

Rex said nothing of the sort. He didn't post on day 2 that he had a night action. He simply voted.
He was a replacement day 2... how could he have a night 1 action?

rules read:

14. I expect you to be active. The game will not survive without activity, so get stuck in. If you know you'll be away from a computer for a certain period of time and may miss a day or night period, just let me know via PM, and as long as you post when you can, no problem. If you are inactive for a full day phase without notifying me of real-life reasons, I will prod you. If you have a night action and do not submit it by the deadline after being prodded, you will be mod-killed. If you don't have a night action, you have until the night period is over to get back to me, otherwise you will be mod-killed.

So what happened was, The guy he replaced didn't respond to the prod with his night action by deadline. So Tritch replaced him.

Deadline is over.

You're telling me that AFTER all that, AC Smith allowed Tritch to get a night action?

You can SAY whatever you want, but what I've presented are facts.

so NOW ur saying that rex's info was inreliable when he came up town watcher. how many more townies r u gonna get killed terry? for all u no, rex was rdy to replace and yes smith allowed a nite action. look at the time stamps of when he posted to replace and when smith posted the day 2 phase. just fess up and admit it, u been caught.

[T-Marv]

WE DONT KNOW WHAT REX's INFO IS! Now you're just stretching as usual as well as putting words into my mouth.
I haven't been caught. You have and you've spent the last 2 days trying to weasel out of it.

Coming out stomping your feet screaming that I've been caught when you damn well know that's false. Cause I know what side I'm on... you know what side I'm on, and you know I'm telling the truth.

[T-Marv]

THANK YOU Raab... Let's wrap this day up so I can do my victory dance.

Remember what I laid out for the next night and day people to watch.

[A.C. Smith]

That is a LYNCH as of Raab's vote! No more talking.

DEAD: Reaver - Doc Hopper - Mafia Hitman

Night Three begins NOW, and will end at 2 p.m. Eastern time (11 a.m. Pacific) on TUESDAY, JANUARY 14TH. I will be sending prods to inactive players, so if you didn't post during this day phase, make sure you respond.

[A.C. Smith]

Evening. Our opening act tonight at the Muppet Theater is Dr. Teeth and the Electric Mayhem, and they kick off with a classic interrupted by Sam the Eagle.



The crowd cheers, and the band goes into its second song.

Dr. Teeth: "Animal, go crazy on those drums, man!"

Animal: "DRUM! DRUM! DRUM!"

However, the second Animal bangs the drums…

BOOM!!!!!

The entire stage explodes. The crowd runs for the exits while Dr. Teeth, Animal, and the rest of the band are burnt to a crisp, all thanks to the latest attack by Tex Richman and Long John Silver.

Statler: (applauding) "MORE! MORE! MORE!"

DEAD: Evan - Dr. Teeth - Town Doctor
MODKILLED (inactivity): justinp - Animal - Town One-Shot Night Vigilante

1) Rebel
2) Speede
3) Madison
4) Reya Serra
5) The Last King
6) Raab
7) T-Marv
8) C.J. Gates
9) Deas
10) Fresh

With 10 players alive, it takes SIX votes for a lynch and THREE votes to enable role-claiming.

Day Four begins NOW, and will end at 4 p.m. Eastern time (1 p.m. Pacific) on FRIDAY, JANUARY 17TH.

[T-Marv]

Was roleblocked again... I suspect as much. But before I get on with the next day phase...

*Does Victory Dance* BOOOOOOYYYYYAAAAAAA!

We lost two town, that sucks. Justin was inactive, but that one shot vig would have been nice. We lost a doctor... that blows big time.

For now, I'm willing to
vote: Statler
Based on Reya's info.

[T-Marv]

LMAO
EBOWP

vote: Rebel

[Reya Serra]

Vote: Rebel

Going back to my vote from last day phase. Though I'm still no more certain about Rebel than I was before, with Terry all but confirmed to be town, Rebel appears the most likely to be Statler.

Still plenty of time to talk though so no need to rush.

[Speede]

Glad we got one! I went to bed and came back to see Raab already made the hammer. As of right now, I'm confident Marv is town, Raab is likely town seeing as she hammered scum, and I'm willing to believe Reya is scum as well, so on that note, I'm looking at Madison as my top suspect. When Reaver tried to hit Terry to begin day 3, it was Madison that followed Reaver's vote almost immediately, and with Reaver having flipped scum, I'm inclined to believe Madison Will, as well.

As well, I like the theory about Rebel, but I'm willing to wait momentarily until we hear from him. Right now, my top suspect for scum is Madison.

[Reya Serra]

Jan 14, 2014 19:20:34 GMT -4 Speede said:

Glad we got one! I went to bed and came back to see Raab already made the hammer. As of right now, I'm confident Marv is town, Raab is likely town seeing as she hammered scum, and I'm willing to believe Reya is scum as well, so on that note, I'm looking at Madison as my top suspect. When Reaver tried to hit Terry to begin day 3, it was Madison that followed Reaver's vote almost immediately, and with Reaver having flipped scum, I'm inclined to believe Madison Will, as well.

As well, I like the theory about Rebel, but I'm willing to wait momentarily until we hear from him. Right now, my top suspect for scum is Madison.

I'm going to guess and say that you meant to say that you think I'm town and not scum...

[Johnny Rebel]

So, the evidence against me at the moment is that Reya blocked me and made a gut assumption about my role?

[fresh]

I agree with whats been above. Right now Marv and Reya look town and I have a strong town read on Raab. I need to read back on past posts but I believe Reya said she used her action on Rebel both nights?

[Speede]

Jan 14, 2014 19:39:04 GMT -4 Reya Serra said:

Jan 14, 2014 19:20:34 GMT -4 Speede said:

Glad we got one! I went to bed and came back to see Raab already made the hammer. As of right now, I'm confident Marv is town, Raab is likely town seeing as she hammered scum, and I'm willing to believe Reya is scum as well, so on that note, I'm looking at Madison as my top suspect. When Reaver tried to hit Terry to begin day 3, it was Madison that followed Reaver's vote almost immediately, and with Reaver having flipped scum, I'm inclined to believe Madison Will, as well.

As well, I like the theory about Rebel, but I'm willing to wait momentarily until we hear from him. Right now, my top suspect for scum is Madison.

I'm going to guess and say that you meant to say that you think I'm town and not scum...

Yes, yes I did. My bad!

[Reya Serra]

Jan 14, 2014 20:43:35 GMT -4 fresh said:

I agree with whats been above. Right now Marv and Reya look town and I have a strong town read on Raab. I need to read back on past posts but I believe Reya said she used her action on Rebel both nights?

Yes, I did...as well as last night on the thought that Statler's actions could only be performed on odd nights. Aside from my attempts all being successful, the only evidence supporting my theory that Rebel is Statler stems from the Night 1 writeup.

[fresh]

I am interested in then seeing if Rebel has a defense or if its just to cast doubt about your reasoning.

["The Last King"]

Alright I'm back. Sorry for the inactivity last day phase. I read over everything and I honestly can't come to a conclusion. It's pretty much confirmed that Marv and Reya are town (And I'm leaning towards Raab for town as well), but from what I saw Rebel didn't do much to deserve a vote. I'm gonna read over it again and come back to it.

[Johnny Rebel]

Jan 14, 2014 21:06:23 GMT -4 Reya Serra said:

Jan 14, 2014 20:43:35 GMT -4 fresh said:

I agree with whats been above. Right now Marv and Reya look town and I have a strong town read on Raab. I need to read back on past posts but I believe Reya said she used her action on Rebel both nights?

Yes, I did...as well as last night on the thought that Statler's actions could only be performed on odd nights. Aside from my attempts all being successful, the only evidence supporting my theory that Rebel is Statler stems from the Night 1 writeup.

I'm not sure what else needs to be defended.

He's basing his entire argument on the fact that she threw a block at me on the very first night and it was successful. I've been unable to help the town because every night phase I've been blocked.

I've essentially been reduced to useless in the game because of a hunch (that's incorrect). If Reya's theory was correct about their being an odd night recruiter, there should have been a recruit last night, or at least the appearance of an attempted one. Seeing that there was none - I'd say she's wrong and barking up the wrong tree. Considering there are only 2 or 3 active participants at the moment, if I was Statler, it would be suicide to not try and recruit one of them. Whoever Statler is - they aren't playing a very good game.

In my eyes, the only person that can be cleared at the moment is TMarv. I know I'm not scum of any type but my role is powerless with me being blocked during every phase. Nobody else has been cleared, which is odd considering we're on day 3.

[Reya Serra]

Jan 14, 2014 22:56:38 GMT -4 Johnny Rebel said:

Jan 14, 2014 21:06:23 GMT -4 Reya Serra said:

Yes, I did...as well as last night on the thought that Statler's actions could only be performed on odd nights. Aside from my attempts all being successful, the only evidence supporting my theory that Rebel is Statler stems from the Night 1 writeup.

I'm not sure what else needs to be defended.

He's basing his entire argument on the fact that she threw a block at me on the very first night and it was successful. I've been unable to help the town because every night phase I've been blocked.

I've essentially been reduced to useless in the game because of a hunch (that's incorrect). If Reya's theory was correct about their being an odd night recruiter, there should have been a recruit last night, or at least the appearance of an attempted one. Seeing that there was none - I'd say she's wrong and barking up the wrong tree. Considering there are only 2 or 3 active participants at the moment, if I was Statler, it would be suicide to not try and recruit one of them. Whoever Statler is - they aren't playing a very good game.

In my eyes, the only person that can be cleared at the moment is TMarv. I know I'm not scum of any type but my role is powerless with me being blocked during every phase. Nobody else has been cleared, which is odd considering we're on day 3.

It was successful Night 1 AND the write-up for Night 1 reflected that action.

Jan 10, 2014 2:52:30 GMT -4 A.C. Smith said:

Evening. We see Statler and Waldorf in their balcony, speaking to an attendant.

Statler: “Is she coming?”

Attendant: “No, sir, she said she was busy.”

Waldorf: “That pig.”

Statler: “Literally!”

Both: “BOH HO HO HO HO HO HO!”

I've spent the last two nights attempting to confirm you being Statler a 100% certainty, which I have been unable to do because of the likelihood that you can only act on odd nights combined with your knowledge that I have been targeting you. You could have very easily chosen not to act at all rather than perform an action, which I doubt would be reflected in a writeup at all.

["The Last King"]

Jan 14, 2014 22:56:38 GMT -4 Johnny Rebel said:

Jan 14, 2014 21:06:23 GMT -4 Reya Serra said:

Yes, I did...as well as last night on the thought that Statler's actions could only be performed on odd nights. Aside from my attempts all being successful, the only evidence supporting my theory that Rebel is Statler stems from the Night 1 writeup.

I'm not sure what else needs to be defended.

He's basing his entire argument on the fact that she threw a block at me on the very first night and it was successful. I've been unable to help the town because every night phase I've been blocked.

I've essentially been reduced to useless in the game because of a hunch (that's incorrect). If Reya's theory was correct about their being an odd night recruiter, there should have been a recruit last night, or at least the appearance of an attempted one. Seeing that there was none - I'd say she's wrong and barking up the wrong tree. Considering there are only 2 or 3 active participants at the moment, if I was Statler, it would be suicide to not try and recruit one of them. Whoever Statler is - they aren't playing a very good game.

In my eyes, the only person that can be cleared at the moment is TMarv. I know I'm not scum of any type but my role is powerless with me being blocked during every phase. Nobody else has been cleared, which is odd considering we're on day 3.

That is a good point actually. With everyone being slain left and right, town (or anyone with info) want to hold their cards close to their chests. But we're three days in and we have practically nothing.