South Park Mafia Fall Out Thread

[President Jeff]

ROLES

Mafia

CJ
You are, Eric Cartman , the Mafia Godfather - Each Night you PM the Mod with the person you want Killed
Here is your QT: www.quicktopic.com/46/H/H8XGvWEduuPd


Johnny Rebel
You are, Leopold “Butters” Stotch (During the day) Professor Khaos (During the night), The Mafia Role Blocker - each night you can block someone’s role.
Here is your QT: www.quicktopic.com/46/H/H8XGvWEduuPd


Sally
You are, Craig Tucker, The Mafia Janitor - Each night after a kill, you clean up the body. Once the Kill has been announced, the town won't learn the Townie's role
Here is your QT: www.quicktopic.com/46/H/H8XGvWEduuPd



TOWN

Kurt
You are Clyde Donovan , A Town Traitor - You are pro mafia, but not in the mafia. You know who the mafia is, but they don’t know that you are a traitor. You win when Mafia wins. When investigated, you come up town. You use your vote to help mafia win

The Mafia are: CJ Gates, Johnny Rebel & Sally Talfourd


Jason Kash
You are Officer Barbrady, The town Insane Cop - Each night you get to investigate someone

Branden Harvey
You are Jesus, The town Healer - Each Night you get to protect someone.

Stephan Hart
You are Kenny McCormick, a townie - Once you are Killed (by Mafia or Lynch) you come back to life after a day. Example, if you die on day one, you come back on day 3

Pence
You are, Stan Marsh, a Townie - You can’t be the first person to vote for someone

Level One
You are Kyle Broflovski, The townie Role Blocker - Each night you get to block someone’s role

Ebirah
You are, Randy Marsh - You are a townie who is a Jack of All Trades. Meaning you have the Ability to Protect, Investigate and Role Block. You can only use each of these skills once in the game

Biggs
You are Jimmy Valmer, the Town Comedian. You must talk like the Jimmy character (Do your best with it) and make at least 1 joke each day

JC
You are Terrance and Phillip. You are part of the town and you can vote the same person twice or vote 2 different people

Blade
You are Towlie. You are part of the town. Because Towlie is a stoner and forgetful, During the day, you can't vote.

NIGHT ACTIONS

Night 1 Actions

Level One Blocks Branden from Protecting anyone
Branden Protects himself, which fails
Kash Investigates Sally, she comes up Town due to the Insane Cop Role
Ebirah use 1 of his 3 roles and protects CJ
Rebel Role Blocks No one
CJ Kills JC
Sally cleans up JC’s Role

Note: JC’s 2nd vote on Day 1 was for himself


Night 2 Action

Ebirah uses his 2nd Role to investigate Level One
Level One Role Blocks Ebirah preventing Ebirah to gain Information on him
Branden Protects Level One
Rebel blocks Noble
Jason Investigates Branden
CJ Kills Jason Kash
Sally Cleans up Jason’s Role

(Tmarv takes over for Sally)

Day 3: Branden Gets Lynched

Night 3 Actions:
Level One role blocks Pence
Ebirah Role Blocks no one
Rebel Role Blocks Noble
CJ Kills Ebirah
Tmarv Cleans up Ebirah’s Role

Night 4 Actions
Lester Role Blocks Kurt Noble who has no role
Rebel Role Blocks Lester, which does nothing
CJ Kills Level One
Tmarv cleans up Level One’s Role


Night 5 Action
Rebel Role Blocks No One
CJ Kills Biggs to win the game
Tmarv Cleans up Biggs role

[President Jeff]

This was my first Mafia game that I was the Mod. Please leave honest feedback about the game it self and how I did. Tell me what you like and didn't like. I plan on moding more Mafia games and I want to be better at it.

[brandenharvey]

It was a fun game. But you kinda stacked the deck against the town with the traitor, the non-voter, and the extra vote each lynch.

[Stephan Hart]

Well at least I got T-Marv and CJ correct. I did say I had my eyes on Rebel due to lack of help in the game. usually he simply comes on agrees with some and vote. Was wrong about Biggs! Was suspicious about Noble, but simply couldn't get a read on him. why I was suspicious, he played very similar like the last game, just that he was more active. I pretty much figured Rebel was mafia, because he could have been the vote to take out T-Marv and continue the game, but he decided to waste the vote on me with just minutes left with deadline, with the excuse that I played the game different from the previous one, while salTal was the one to commend me early in the game for playing a little smarter. At the time he had no problem with that.

Like I said my ability would have worked to help the town early in the game. If I was killed or lynched, I'll come back a day later. Mafia taking me out would have been a waste for one night. Biggs you Jimmy retard lol you should have listened to me. lol

With that said, I agree with Harvey, Mafia had a slight advantage with their traitor and a towel for Townie, who couldn't vote.

I think if I had know the rules and retracted my vote earlier, before Harvey being lynched the game might have went a little different.

[President Jeff]

Blade not being able to vote was countered with JC being able to vote twice. It just happened he got killed on day 1

The traitor role got countered with Ebirah's role where he had 3 night roles to use. But the Traitor role didn't effect anything since there we're 9 town members with the Mafia not knowing Kurt was a traitor

[C.J. Gates]

Aside from the two flubs (the thing with Blades vote at the beginning and then changing the number of votes in the last day, though the latter only helped tell the town how many mafia there were) I find it was well modded. Liked the write ups, and the theme was pretty good.

Knowing now (or I guess at the alst day) that Blade was Towlie makes his earlier posts more sensical where he kept saying "I forget". I assume that was supposed to be a tip to him being Towlie since Towlie would be too stoned to remember.

I will agree with others, the town had a lot of roles that worked against them. Might have been better if one of the no vote/double vote roles hadn't been included (even though it was countered with something it still seemed to put them behind a bit in a game of this size).

ALSO, the town could have used more roles to help them identify who was scum. With only the two (Insane Cop and Jack of All Trades) with investigative roles, it kind of hindered them in their ability to hunt scum. By the end there was more of an idea of who was red, but at the beginning it seemed to drag the game down with no one really having anything to contribute.

Overall though, it was well done.

As for the game itself...

It seemed to drag at times, though I think that has to do with a lack of investigative roles to help push people forward. It all ended up relying on posts and, while a lot of people were busy, it just seemed to stall at spots for days before someone picked it back up.

I'll add more later...

[Kurt]

I thought it was a solid game. I'll admit, it definitely slowed down once Day 1 ended, but a number of factors attributed to that, like Sally going MIA and a general lack of information flowing through. I think people could have been prodded to be more active, but most people post at least once per day phase. The lack of lynches definitely slowed the game down a bit.

The write-ups were pretty entertaining, and definitely stayed true to the characters. I think one thing to work on for the next game would be just try and clear up some confusions. The rules said roleclaiming wasn't allowed for this game, and Branden not getting reprimanded for doing so led us to believe he was lying, so he got lynched for it. Also occurred later on with L1 and never really got addressed.

I didn't feel like the game was stacked one way or another. I mean, if you look at it, the town had a protector, Jack of all Trades, Roleblocker, someone that got revived, a doublevoter, and only a few restricting roles. I know my Traitor role helped the mafia, but since they didn't know I was the traitor, I still had quite a few night actions against me which helped level the field.

All in all, pretty solid. Some minor things here and there, but I feel like unfortunate circumstances slowed down the game more than anything. Still fun though.

[President Jeff]

Technically I should have modkilled the roleclaimers, But at the time, there was little activity, so I just said fuck it and left them in the game cause rather I modkill them your not, they we're gonna get Lynched (Especially Branden)

Thanks for the feedback guys, really appreciate it

[brandenharvey]

Honestly, I read "stole the rules from Branden" and didn't bother to read them because I knew what my rules were. It wasn't until after I roleclaimed and everyone was telling me that I was going to get modkilled that I went back and read the rules and realized you edited that one.

[President Jeff]

Yah, thats what I had figured Branden

[Michael Jennings]

Yeah the roleclaiming is something that I didn't like. However this was a well run game. However the town really shot itself in the foot and the mafia took full advantage of it so kudos to them.