|
|
Post by Jules on May 8, 2012 9:49:58 GMT -4
Agree with the above that the write-up is a bit of a mystery. I guess the people we want to hear from now are Noble, Callahan, Jeff and possibly Level-One. I'd like to hear more from Noble about his night 1 intel and whether subsequent events shed further light on it all.
|
|
|
|
Post by Johnny Rebel on May 8, 2012 9:54:12 GMT -4
I've tried to follow Jeff unsuccessfully for two nights now -- and while I'm not convinced that he's scum yet, his ability to hide at night raises some red flags.
|
|
|
|
Post by Jules on May 8, 2012 10:34:26 GMT -4
I've tried to follow Jeff unsuccessfully for two nights now -- and while I'm not convinced that he's scum yet, his ability to hide at night raises some red flags. Did you get any results at all? I ask this because it may gives us some idea of Jeff's role. I remember you saying you tried to follow Jeff night 1 but got sent elsewhere. Has this happened since? Or have your investigations into Jeff returned 'inconclusive' or 'unsuccessful' results? |
|
|
|
Post by Kurt on May 8, 2012 10:38:19 GMT -4
On my kindle + not home today. I will definitely have a response + info within 12 hours.
|
|
|
|
Post by Johnny Rebel on May 8, 2012 10:43:57 GMT -4
I'm treading lightly here with trying not to be mod-killed -- but he was unable to be found.
|
|
|
|
Post by Jake Venom on May 8, 2012 11:25:14 GMT -4
Hm. Interesting.
Here's what I'm seeing so far. Level One had enough votes to be lynched. When the write up came, we found out that he wasn't. Maybe he was saved, or maybe something else was going on.
Now, today, we see a write-up where Skroob should have been killed, but apparently he used a decoy to save himself. I think this is some of the most telling evidence, combined with the fact that Level One was quick to pile onto the Knuckles bandwagon when that lynch train had momentum, and that he visited Sally the same that she just happened to die... Well, that raises some huge red flags.
Vote: Level One
|
|
|
|
Post by Michael Callahan on May 8, 2012 12:21:10 GMT -4
I'm treading lightly here with trying not to be mod-killed -- but he was unable to be found. You don't get mod-killed for roleclaiming, T-Marv just doesn't want you to do it. I'm on my phone atm so like Kurt, I'll have more for the board later. |
|
|
|
Post by A.C. Smith on May 8, 2012 12:47:35 GMT -4
First things first: (chest-bumps Callahan for helping lead the lynch parade on Knuckles)
Anyway, I, too, am a little leery of L-1 based on what happened with Sally and the most recent write-up, but I want to wait and hear what information Jeff has that he didn't get to post before Knuckles was lynched. J-Reb being unable to follow him doesn't necessarily mean Jeff is scum, but I would certainly like a little more information before I cast a vote.
|
|
|
|
Post by C.J. Gates on May 8, 2012 12:49:30 GMT -4
I'm treading lightly here with trying not to be mod-killed -- but he was unable to be found. Day 2 you said that instead of Jeff, you were watching someone visit Noble. Did you get put on anyone last night or did you simply get a "not found/inconclusive" result? |
|
|
|
Post by President Jeff on May 8, 2012 15:59:58 GMT -4
I'm not sure why Rebel would get no info on me. I don't have a role that would hide anything I'm doing.
I'll share my info later on tonight, but before I do.
AC, did you use your role last night?
|
|
|
|
Post by A.C. Smith on May 8, 2012 16:51:59 GMT -4
I'll share my info later on tonight, but before I do. AC, did you use your role last night? Yes, I did. |
|
|
|
Post by Michael Jennings on May 8, 2012 22:28:54 GMT -4
Alright from the write-up it seems like Purple Mafia knows who Skroob is and scum team knows who the Ewok is. As for Jeff's info I'm going to come out and clear Callahan as town. That is 100% and should be obvious anyway after the Knuckles lynch. That leaves Gates and Noble. Leaning toward Noble out of the two to be honest about it.
|
|
|
|
Post by T-Marv on May 8, 2012 22:42:12 GMT -4
Vote Count
Level One - 1 (Jake Venom)
Deadline is a Friday 9 am EST
|
|
|
|
Post by Level-Two on May 8, 2012 23:06:11 GMT -4
Hm. Interesting. Here's what I'm seeing so far. Level One had enough votes to be lynched. When the write up came, we found out that he wasn't. Maybe he was saved, or maybe something else was going on. Now, today, we see a write-up where Skroob should have been killed, but apparently he used a decoy to save himself. I think this is some of the most telling evidence, combined with the fact that Level One was quick to pile onto the Knuckles bandwagon when that lynch train had momentum, and that he visited Sally the same that she just happened to die... Well, that raises some huge red flags. Vote: Level OneLOL! I haven't got past this page yet - but nice try to trying to evade the fact that there is scum still on that list and instead pushing this weak milk toast case against me. Huge red flags already, Jake. |
|
|
|
Post by Kurt on May 9, 2012 0:38:21 GMT -4
Sorry for my slightly lengthy delay. I'll hit a few different posts here, starting a fair bit back... I had the same feeling -- and thought I'd so some investigating but somehow I was sent elsewhere seeing someone else visit Kurt Noble. I'll let them out themselves. I would like this name for the sole purpose of helping to establish who the killer is not. I can reach another conclusion about you should you be correct, but I'll elaborate on that when it comes back. But I absolutely need this name when possible. The only thing I am claiming at this point is that I won a power from T-Marv's trivia game - it was a X shot. I just assumed that because you were saying I was scum killer that you'd be watching me. I know you said you watched Sally but then I don't see why you wouldn't watch me. That is my point. I know this is old, so bare with me. I fail to see how mentioning you won a power is relevant when you've already mentioned that you have a power role that you attempted to use to gain information on Sally (explain). If you have information that would be helpful from this power role, I ask that you share it. I would like to be able to believe you're town, but nothing concrete, or anything related to your role has emerged yet. However, you won't see a vote from me on you today, guaranteed. There are more pressing issues at hand. However, I also had another one-shot ability. Maybe because I had no powers I got this - but I suspect that everyone else got one too. But I used it last night as well as my resurrect (knowing full well that no one would be blocking me or suspecting anything from me). The info I got back was that CJ is Town. So that should help narrow down the intel that Jeff gave us, especially when Kaji turned up dead too. It's down to 3, and there's a 66% chance of getting rid of someone at random. If Knuckles turns up town, it's a 100% chance of hitting someone anti-town (assuming Jeff is town - which is what I'm doing as of this moment). Hm, this puts us (read: me) in a weird spot. The remaining people on Jeff's list are myself, CJ, and Callahan. This is where things get fairly interesting: - James clears Callahan. - Sally clears CJ. Assuming the town believes both Sally and James, guess that just leaves me right? Judging from certain posts already, I see that's the way the town is leaning. I'm not going to bitch or whine if the votes start getting stacked on me, but I am going to do my best to provide the town with the information I have in the hopes that it'll clear me. Speaking of information, albeit useless, I watched myself Night 2 in the hopes that L1 would use his aforementioned ability on me, validating my ability and his; sadly, no one visited me night 2. I'll get to Night 3 in just a bit. [/quote] Hm. Interesting. Here's what I'm seeing so far. Level One had enough votes to be lynched. When the write up came, we found out that he wasn't. Maybe he was saved, or maybe something else was going on. Now, today, we see a write-up where Skroob should have been killed, but apparently he used a decoy to save himself. I think this is some of the most telling evidence, combined with the fact that Level One was quick to pile onto the Knuckles bandwagon when that lynch train had momentum, and that he visited Sally the same that she just happened to die... Well, that raises some huge red flags. Vote: Level OneThis posts makes absolutely no sense, and paints you in a horrible light. How do we know L1 connects with the decoy? It's speculative reasoning based on nothing. L1 did not receive the votes necessary for a lynch on Day 2 either. As far as band-wagoning, you voted for Knuckles AFTER L1 did, further on his wagon. Not focusing on Jeff's info today seems odd, as it should be an issue for today. Moreover, yes, L1 did visit Sally Night 1, but this post starkly contrasts how you opened Day 3. I absolutely agree with Gates. We're in a situation where a) Sally was killed (and brought back all Carrie style) and b) we know that Noble visited Sally that night, which is a particularly interesting bit of information. Twist the "interesting bit of information" bit all you'd like, but you're clearly leaning on me with this post. I'm just failing to understand your jump in thought here. So, to be clear, because you're the only one down with a vote, you're voting for L1 off my information and the write-up? I'll have more up in the morning. |
|
|
|
Post by Level-Two on May 9, 2012 1:05:04 GMT -4
Kurt,
The power role I won (Xshot) differs from my original role. My visit on Sally night one gave me no information because she was night killed. Yes, I could share insight into my role but with two killers in the game and not a likely candidate for protection - scum is just going to take a guess and decide themselves if I am worth it.
Furthermore - I am not content with your info, Kurt. You swore up and down that I was scum. On night two - you should have been following me. Period. If you did - we wouldn't be here and I'd be cleared by you already.
I am confused as to why you still haven't cleared me and my only guess is that you want to eventually circle back onto me for an excuse for a vote and you can't do that if you've cleared me.
Between you, CJ and Callahan - you are my main suspect on that list.
Originally I thought you were a watcher but now as that list narrows down - I am starting to wonder if you actually have a scum aligned journalist role.
However, Jake Venom's vote sticks out as a huge scum tell so I agree with you on that front.
|
|
|
|
Post by C.J. Gates on May 9, 2012 1:13:40 GMT -4
I had the same feeling -- and thought I'd so some investigating but somehow I was sent elsewhere seeing someone else visit Kurt Noble. I'll let them out themselves. I would like this name for the sole purpose of helping to establish who the killer is not. I can reach another conclusion about you should you be correct, but I'll elaborate on that when it comes back. But I absolutely need this name when possible. I am also interested in this person's name. If they're still alive, they might be able to provide us with some information that they might have got from visiting Noble night one. The only thing holding me back from voting for Noble is that he saw Level One visit Sally...I don't know a role that could kill and watch at the same time. Hoping that name can provide some insight into all of this. I'm also still interested in what happened to Rebel last night, whether he went elsewhere or was just given a no. I also agree with James, that someone knows who Skroob is, though probably won't come forward with it since they're the last third party member left and would end up outing themselves. |
|
|
|
Post by C.J. Gates on May 9, 2012 1:14:43 GMT -4
EWOP
There could be a chance that Skroob was targeted by a one shot vig or something from a quiz, but still, I'd think that someone should know who Skroob is.
|
|
|
|
Post by SalTal on May 9, 2012 2:54:24 GMT -4
Just getting through this all, but I'd like to ask two things:
- How many scum have we seen and how many do we speculate there are?
- I'd like to hear more from Callahan, seeings how his name is in the mix as being a potential scum, specifically as much as he can in regards to getting info on Knuckles and how he was able to work with AC.
|
|
|
|
Post by SalTal on May 9, 2012 3:01:13 GMT -4
Here's what I'm seeing so far. Level One had enough votes to be lynched. When the write up came, we found out that he wasn't. Maybe he was saved, or maybe something else was going on. I can actually answer this, and can definitively say why the lynch didn’t happen. |
|
|
|
Post by Michael Callahan on May 9, 2012 3:19:50 GMT -4
- How many scum have we seen and how many do we speculate there are? - I'd like to hear more from Callahan, seeings how his name is in the mix as being a potential scum, specifically as much as he can in regards to getting info on Knuckles and how he was able to work with AC. From what I've read in the write-ups there was five, now four non-town characters in the game. Three Scum, Two Third Party. My info came from my role. As I said in the night thread when I asked for protection. As for AC? He knew Knuckles wasn't town-aligned and pointed that out. So I decided to take a gamble and spill my night information to take a gamble on my life. Luckily it paid off.  |
|
|
|
Post by SalTal on May 9, 2012 3:21:38 GMT -4
Ok, here goes ... Here's what I'm seeing so far. Level One had enough votes to be lynched. When the write up came, we found out that he wasn't. Maybe he was saved, or maybe something else was going on. I can actually answer this, and can definitively say why the lynch didn’t happen. But just bear with me. As for Jeff's info I'm going to come out and clear Callahan as town. That is 100% and should be obvious anyway after the Knuckles lynch. Actually, I have two things to say about this. 1) It doesn’t prove Callahan isn’t scum, it proves he’s mostly likely not third party, and; 2) I believe that Callahan is possibly scum because I can account for everyone else in Jeff’s list. So bear with me. Yes, I lied yesterday. I said I had no night role. I do, but I needed to make sure that no one at all tried to do anything to me - roleblock, kill, etc. - so that I could gather a whole heap of information. I can confirm, due to my Night One night action, that I am town and not insane. I can confirm, due to my Night Two night action, that CJ Gates is town. I can confirm, due to a starting one-shot, that Kurt Noble is town. I can confirm, due to Night Three’s night action that Level-One is town. HOWEVER ... I can also confirm that Callahan stopped the lynch on Level-One Day Two. I know he did. By putting into his post ‘I’m surrounded by asshole’ he stopped the lynch. How do I know? TMarv said that the day ended with the #150 post - that was Callahan and that was what he put in bold. It was a one-shot ability that he had, because that’s the same way I had to use my one-shot ability. I’m 99% confident on that. No, forget it. I’m 100% certain of it: Callahan prevented a lynch on Level-One. Even after he voted for him. But, ironically, he voted for him *after* he used his one-shot, so he knew it wouldn’t count, but would look like it did. He could say whatever he wanted, but he knew the day was ending there and then. Which is exactly why Level-One (who would have been informed in his scum QT) that this was happening, threw up his hands, had a dummy spit, and said he was done. Jeff confirmed that one of Kaji, Knuckles, CJ, Noble, and Callahan were mafia. Kaji turned up town. Knuckles turned up third party. CJ is confirmed town by me. Noble is confirmed town by me. That leaves Callahan as mafia. Level-One visits me, and I died. The next day, he refuses to role claim to save himself, goes on the aggressive defense (expected) and then, when he gets close to the lynch, has a dummy spit. Callahan saves Level-One from getting lynched. The action after this is perfectly coordinated between Callahan and Level-One to come off a town as possible. During the day, Level-One goes hammer and tong after Kurt, painting him as scum/third party and claiming that someone else went to me during Night 1. Fact of the matter is that it doesn’t gel at all with what Kurt is saying (that Level-One visited). There is the issue of how Kurt missed a killer, a cleaner, and me visiting myself. Don’t worry, Level-One. I know you’re already breathing fire and steam is coming out your ears as you read this. I’ll turn my attention to Kurt in due time. But I would expect that, if you are town, you’d like to completely get through all these details rather than leave any stone unturned. So if you see unreasoned (*not* unreasobable) points, do point them out. Jeff (by process of elimination) fingers Callahan as mafia. Level-One uses this as cover to say that he’s not anti-town, claims to have some information but comes out with nothing, claiming he is waiting for clarification. He justifies the credibility of Callahan’s and AC’s story about Knuckles. During the same day, Callahan throws more suspicion on Kurt. Callahan even throws votes on himself to get to a role claim situation, which I assume he would have lied about something. But then he gets clarification from TMarv and flips immediately onto Knuckles. The had information on Knuckles, yes. But they’ve been sharing it. It’s likely only one of them had any information, and they just worked it between them. Callahan, AC, and Level-One all vote for Knuckles, who turns up third party. Level-One and Callahan, by this theory, are scum. And, because of AC and Callahan working so closely together, AC would make the third member. But, now we have a big problem: That list of Jeff’s, narrowed down with the intel we have, makes Callahan the scum/mafia in it all. Here’s the problem: Callahan stopped the lynch on Level-One, which would suggest they are together, but Level-One comes up town; AC worked heavily with Callahan to get that lynch on Knuckles done, but that would put the scum at 3 (Callahan, AC, Level-One) and causes a problem because JamesV clears Callahan which would suggest they are both scum and puts the number at four and we heavn’t seen four; JamesV may have investigated Callahan and Callahan may have been godfather (thus the town reading) but how would that explain Level-One’s town reading that I got as well if they are both scum? Callahan’s stopping of Level-One’s lynch is a huge problem for him (in my opinion). It compounds a lot of evidence that is floating around to give it more focus. However, I’m sure Level-One and Callahan and AC have something to say about all this, so I won’t keep throwing out theory. It’s above and they can address it. Kurt though, you’re an enigma to me right now. On one hand, you game play is so town-esque that I don’t want to go after you. But there are serious questions that you need to account for If you watched me, how the heck did he not see a killer and a cleaner come as well? When you answer that though, answer this for me: If you watched me, how did he not see me visit myself as well? You said you watched me. Level-One confessed to having visited me, and you said you saw him. But I *know* I visited myself. Definitely, 100% I did. It should be obvious that I did. So now we’ve got a pickle: If a killer and a cleaner visited me, you only saw 1 of the 4 who did. And that’s just a crazy and altogether unbelievable role to have. It’s entirely possible that Kurt is the scum in the list, and that Callahan and Level-One are both town (thus my reading on Level-One is correct), and that Noble is the godfather. This idea has more plausibility, in that there are less contradictions with other information out there. I mean comparing the two: Callahan = Scum --> Jeff’s info = CORRECT; my reading on Level-One = INCORRECT; my reading on Kurt Noble = CORRECT; my reading on CJ Gates = CORRECT Kurt = Scum --> Jeff’s info = CORRECT; my reading on Level-One = CORRECT; my reading on Callahan = CORRECT; my reading on CJ Gates = CORRECT But I’ll leave this aside, because we have a Jeff problem: Jeff produces a list that is proved pretty much correct with the Knuckles/Kaji deaths. Rebel can’t get a reading on him three times (?) or two times. This makes me wonder if the list is at all legitimate or, maybe, if Jeff has fudged it to his own end. That is, he’s part of the scum, got the list, knew to take out his scum buddy’s name, and then published the list knowing full well that a third party was still in there. What does let Jeff off the hook somewhat is if Kurt is actually the godfather. Jeff says he can clear AC (or that AC’s info was 100% correct). Assuming that Jeff can extrapolate that into a town (or near town) reading on AC, that could transfer over to Callahan and clear Callahan. And then Callahan/’s stoping of the lynch on Level-One makes some sense (in that Callahan, being town, wanted to prevent a lynch on who he thought was town). However, Callahan voted for Level-One even when he stopped the lynch. Why would you bother doing that? Maybe to fit into the game, not draw attention to it. I don’t know. There’s two options as I see it. The first one, we lynch Callahan. If Callahan turns up town, we turn to Kurt. If Callahan turns up scum, we turn to Level-One. The second one, we lynch Kurt. If Kurt turns up town, we lynch Callahan. If Kurt turns up scum, then we continue on from the two night’s worth of information. And, as these are all my theories and my information, I’m going to get the ball rolling: Vote: Kurt NobleAs I spelled out before, there are less inconsistencies with assuming you’re the godfather. Also, can I put dibs on being protected tonight??? I think I’m going to need it after all this haha! And it would be worth keeping me around! |
|
|
|
Post by Level-Two on May 9, 2012 4:24:31 GMT -4
Fuck, that's a whole lot of info to get through but here we go...
First off– I had no clue Callahan had stopped the day phase until your post, Sally. I thought it was President Jeff in order to get the names he provided at the end of the day change.
Now that Sally has raised it to my attention...
I am not looking to get into a pissing contest here but the theory that I knew about Callahan saving me and that we had planned it all in advance can be proven to be false by the time stamps. Between the time Callahan stopped the day phase and me ''giving up'' because I supposedly knew I was safe... was two minutes.
Also, my responses that come after that. I remember these specifically because in that moment - I was in a panic because I was near a lynch and then Callahan came in and voted for me as well and everything was just in the spurr of the moment - including accepting defeat.
Still its a valid argument but at the end of the day it's arm chair quarterbacking and you should read those posts over with the time stamps in mind as it will show the true context of it all.
Also, I don't recall this ever happening. I don't think I ever doubted Kurt being town until today's phase. The day after I survived - I asked him why didn't he visit me which he never really answered. I never accused him of being third party at all.. it's just that the list has been narrowed down and I've factored in the possibility he's a watcher variant.
Anyways, I can't speak for Callahan but my educated guess as to why he voted AND used his power to save me – is to cover his track if I was lynched the next day and flipped scum. I really don't think it's a scum tell on his behalf but rather a townie doing his best not to get his ass lynched. Fair game to me. I still don't know why he saved me but it was the right decision.
Thanks for the save anyways. ;D This only solidifies in my mind that Callahan is far more likely to be a townie out of those three for me.
Kurt not checking me out night two after swearing I am scum up and down is more suspect then anything. If he ever thought I was innocent he didn't bother clearing me which doesn't sound like a town move to me. In fact he didn't seem to care whether or not I was lynched and that's a huge problem.
I now believe he used some sort of journalist ability on me. Pretty much the same thing he had last game with Alisha, I'd imagine.
I won't be voting for the guy who saved my life and CJ Gates hasn't done much to warrant a vote in my direction so as of now I will...
Vote: Kurt Noble
|
|
|
|
Post by Level-Two on May 9, 2012 4:48:12 GMT -4
EWOP: I'd just like to add before I am off to bed that as I think about it even MORE - Kurt may not even be the watcher but rather someone is his QT has had the ability and they were sharing information. The same way Knuckles pretended to clear Jeff last day phase meanwhile he was the godfather.
That's all I got. I'll check back in tomorrow folks.
|
|
|
|
Post by SalTal on May 9, 2012 6:13:28 GMT -4
The way you replied, Level-One, is so unlike the way you reply when you're scum that I'm more comfortable with voting for Kurt haha! But maybe you've changed that all up. Either way, despite knowing that you'd be on the short list should Kurt come up scum, you took it all very well!
But just some details.
Yes timestamps suggest you were all posting at around the same time, but Callahan could have easily said that he had the stop lynch one-shot at the start of the game, and then as some point you sorted out in a QT when he should use it (ie. at a number, when you drop a phrase, when you say in a QT). But I admit that that is pushing the theory very far into crazy land. Yes, it's armchair quarterbacking.
Your explanation for Callahan is pretty spot-on to what I was thinking (but didn't right - because I don't want to give someone an easy out when I'm accusing them haha!). I had assumed it was to cover his tracks too if it all went pear-shaped.
I want to point out that if you're believing my information - on yourself, especially - then you should believe my information on CJ.
Your extra points on Kurt are not helpful for him at all. And, to a large extent, I'm going to agree with them.
Thanks for the reply, and for the *constructive* response. Better than being torn to shreds by you haha!
|
|
|
|
Post by A.C. Smith on May 9, 2012 8:26:35 GMT -4
Sally: Do you get paid by the word?  Anyway, I can't vouch for much in this game. But I'm 100% town (otherwise why would I volunteer to lynch myself if Knuckles wasn't third-party?), and the only reason my "alliance" with Callahan came about was because we both got the exact same piece of information (me through a one-shot action I was awarded, I don't know about how he got it). That doesn't necessarily mean he's town; getting rid of the third party would obviously be a boon to both the town and the scum. |
|
|
|
Post by SalTal on May 9, 2012 8:34:05 GMT -4
Sally: Do you get paid by the word? It's a reverse ploy; I'm secretly waiting until someone starts paying me to *not* write so much. |
|
|
|
Post by C.J. Gates on May 9, 2012 9:38:52 GMT -4
I had the same thought about Jeff, Sally. There is always the chance that he could have fudged names if he's on the scum team to save one of his buddies. The one thing that keeps me thinking bad about Jeff is because he keeps saying he has information that will help us know why AC was 100% on Knuckles, but keeps saying he'll tell it later. When Knuckles got lynched, he said he would tell us the next day and when that day came (today) he told us he'd tell us his information last night, which he never did. It seems like he's stringing us along to keep him in the game. However, I feel that, with all the information laid out (in typical Sally fashion  ) that Noble is the best bet. I feel as though we will never know for sure how things are falling out, but if as many people checked Sally night one as is suspect (Noble, Level One, Sally herself PLUS at least a killer) and Noble only saw one, I'd question how his supposed watcher role works. So with that... Vote: Kurt NobleAt the very least, we will get some answers. I'd almost go as far as to say that if Kurt flips town, we take a serious look at Jeff as well as Callahan. Also, as a question to throw out...Callahan was cleared by James...TO JAMES: Is your clear from a night action or just from your perception/how things worked with Knuckles? |
|
|
|
Post by T-Marv on May 9, 2012 10:05:22 GMT -4
Vote Count:
Noble - 3 (level one, sally, CJ Gates)
Level One - 1 (Jake Venom)
With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.
|
|
|
|
Post by Kurt on May 9, 2012 10:08:51 GMT -4
That's 3 of 6. Time for a role-claim + laying out some theories. Furthermore - I am not content with your info, Kurt. You swore up and down that I was scum. On night two - you should have been following me. Period. If you did - we wouldn't be here and I'd be cleared by you already. I am confused as to why you still haven't cleared me and my only guess is that you want to eventually circle back onto me for an excuse for a vote and you can't do that if you've cleared me. Originally I thought you were a watcher but now as that list narrows down - I am starting to wonder if you actually have a scum aligned journalist role. I am a watcher (although I was originally led to believe I was a tracker because of my role PM). Although, judging from this post, you're mistaken as to how the watcher role works. I can't "follow" anyone - that's a tracker. The only way I can see you visit someone is if I specifically target the same person you target, ala Sally Night 1. Because I can't randomly predict who you will target, I used my ability on myself Night 2 - because if you had an "information gathering" ability, you would use it on me to help us both out. That's why I didn't target you Night 2: because I can't pinpoint who you target. I do have some information from Night 3 that I will spill in a moment though. It'll be a nightmare quoting Sally's post, so I'm just gonna use bolding. |
|
) that Noble is the best bet. I feel as though we will never know for sure how things are falling out, but if as many people checked Sally night one as is suspect (Noble, Level One, Sally herself PLUS at least a killer) and Noble only saw one, I'd question how his supposed watcher role works. So with that...
