Batman Mafia (Day 6)

[yarmouth1]

I too think that Gooch is been too defensive, But saying that the last game we had and he was scum he played it dumb and worked well for him no offence pal.

So this time he may be telling the truth, Jewels is on my raider too his comments for me seem a little suspect so for that reason I vote: Jewels (spelling) lol.

[Michael Jennings]

Dec 14, 2012 3:13:52 GMT -4 Michael Callahan said:

I always appreciate a good Limp Bizkit reference.

Vote: Callahan

Adding nothing to the game. I don't think Jules is scum and after reading through everything and thinking about it the thing that comes to mind is that town is arguing too much over stupid crap. In my opinion this day phase has been a waste with people arguing over nothing and others just not giving a crap and adding nothing like in the quoted post.

[Michael Callahan]

Dec 14, 2012 10:51:14 GMT -4 Michael Jennings said:

Dec 14, 2012 3:13:52 GMT -4 Michael Callahan said:

I always appreciate a good Limp Bizkit reference.

Vote: Callahan

Adding nothing to the game. I don't think Jules is scum and after reading through everything and thinking about it the thing that comes to mind is that town is arguing too much over stupid crap. In my opinion this day phase has been a waste with people arguing over nothing and others just not giving a crap and adding nothing like in the quoted post.

Bit drastic like. I've got nothing to add that hasn't already been covered, no insight, no opinion. Useless, I know, but hardly lynch worthy.

[T-Marv]

This game is getting quite ridiculous. I know of at LEAST two Vanillas, and one is dead.

The only info out there is people being "cleared" and with no counter claim I tend to believe it.

[KJE]

I want to believe Jeff's clearing of Phenom but I can't. It's not Jeff that is making it that way either its Phenom. He hinted at a role he could use to help town with but the first night he wouldnt be able to help... night two he still gave nothing. How is it he still has nothing? Makes no sense.

[President Jeff]

Dec 14, 2012 16:40:27 GMT -4 KJE said:

I want to believe Jeff's clearing of Phenom but I can't. It's not Jeff that is making it that way either its Phenom. He hinted at a role he could use to help town with but the first night he wouldnt be able to help... night two he still gave nothing. How is it he still has nothing? Makes no sense.

Could be a 1 shot role

Its up to you if you want to believe me or not.

[KJE]

He hinted towards cop from what I gathered. Which is why I am trying to get him to enlighten as best as he can without saying too much but hes avoiding it completely. Town dont have much to go off of and this is becoming insane.

[Level-Two]

Dec 14, 2012 6:33:57 GMT -4 yarmouth1 said:

I too think that Gooch is been too defensive, But saying that the last game we had and he was scum he played it dumb and worked well for him no offence pal.

So this time he may be telling the truth, Jewels is on my raider too his comments for me seem a little suspect so for that reason I vote: Jewels (spelling) lol.

Can someone remind me why do we think your town again? You're just as suspicious as anyone else. You've been scum twice in a row - so I guess your getting a pass based on that alone but you're playing the exact same way.

You parrot whatever is most popular and tag along with whatever the vote of the day has started off with.

[KJE]

Yeah I dont see anyone as clear except those I have had checked. Everyone else I am still suspicious of. L1.... I have an idea of who I am going to check based off of everything and the statements that were said... any thoughts from you who would be the best bet tonight?

[Level-Two]

Dec 14, 2012 18:09:07 GMT -4 KJE said:

Yeah I dont see anyone as clear except those I have had checked. Everyone else I am still suspicious of. L1.... I have an idea of who I am going to check based off of everything and the statements that were said... any thoughts from you who would be the best bet tonight?

There is too much back and forth on Jules. Depending on how he flips, we may have some insight on who look at next. And for that reason, we need a watcher on you tonight.

[KJE]

Yeah I was thinking Jules too. Hes a great player and I would rather clear those who are good at hunting things out so I am glad we agree on that. Good looking!

[The Soul Of Philly]

THATS IT! DAY 3 ENDED AT THREE

Sorry, 3 funerals today, 6 to set up for tomorrow. I'll have a write up hopefully by the end of the night, I'm beat and gonna take a nap.

Have all night actions into me by say 6 PM EST Saturday, 12/15.

[The Soul Of Philly]

Sorry, I'm gonna push the deadline back a couple hours, midnight tonite. I've been battling a bug all day.

[The Soul Of Philly]

Night. We find ourselves outside of the Gotham News building where we see Vicki Vale leaving the building. She turns to her right and heads for the parking garage down the block. As she makes her way to the car she finds her car covered in ice.

Mr. Freeze: Looks like someone boxed you in.

Vicki turns around to see The Super Criminals waiting for her. Harley leaps at her as the scene goes dark.

HAHAHAHAAHAHAAHAAAAAHAHAHAA

---

Night. We find ourselves in the Batcave where we see Batman, Nightwing, Robin, Alfred, and Oracle in the cave.

Robin: Bruce, what do we do now? They’ve hit us close to home last night.

Batman: We find them, take them in.

Nightwing: Blood for blood I say. They kill one of ours, we kill them.

B atman: Then we are no different from them.

Alfred: Master Bruce, maybe Master Dick is right.

Batman: Alfred. What are you talking about?

Alfred: Maybe the only way to keep Gotham safe, is to cut the source of pain at the head.

Batman: No. We are not them, they don’t have rules. We do. That is what makes us different. Now, you can leave and fight justice or be with us and fight injustice. Now, what is it?

Alfred: I have always fought for justice and I always will, until my death.

Robin: Oracle, you find anything?

Oracle: No, the computer isn’t working. Let’s see the news.

She turns on the news to find a chopper view of the ACE Chemical Lab building where there are two people on the roof: The Joker and Vicki Vale. Joker has a megaphone.

The Joker: People of Gotham, lend me your ears! Miss Vale has already has.

We see Vicki bleeding from the side of her ears.

The Joker: I’ve been free for Arkham for three days. To commemorate the longest time out of Arkham, I have decided to throw a little shindig from this roof and Batman is the guest of honor. Bats you have until midnight otherwise, the shindig won’t be the only thing being thrown from this roof.

Vicki Vale: BATMAN! HELP!

---

Night. The roof of ACE Chemicals.

Vicki Vale: Please, don’t kill me.

The Joker: I won’t at least, not until after I kill Batman.

Just then a Baterang comes flying in, knocking the gun out of the hand of The Joker as Batman swoops in and kicks Joker. Nightwing and Robin come in and tend to Vicki Vale. As they are, Harley Quinn and Mr. Freeze come from under the roof and start to fight with the sidekicks.

Harley Quinn: Hey there bird brains.

Nightwing throws a baton at her face, which connects.

Mr. Freeze: You shouldn’t have done that.

Freeze freezes the baton to the roof. The four of them fight while Batman and Joker are fighting. Much into the fight, Vicki Vale grabs the gun and points it at Joker.

Vicki Vale: Die you sick clown freak!

She pulls the trigger.

BZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZTTTTZTZTTZZZZZZZZZZZZT

Vale is shocked by the gun as it was a trick gun. She staggers to her left, and falls off the roof of the building. At the same time, Harley and Freeze have Robin on the ropes, so to speak, as Nightwing jumps after Vicki Vale. The duo is too much for the young sidekick as they overpower him and throw him off the roof as well.

Batman: ROBIN! NO!

He punches Joker and runs for the edge of the roof. He leaps off and shoots a grappling rope at Robin. He saves him about 15 feet of the ground, while Nightwing wasn’t so lucky as he could not get to Vicki Vale before she hit the ground. The GCPD makes their way to the building as The Joker shoots out the light on the chopper allowing The Super Criminals to get away.

DEAD:Callahan – Vicki Vale – Town Tracker

1. Yarmouth
2. President Jeff
3. Mark Mania
4. AC Smith
5. Sally
6. L1
7. JamesV
8. KJE
9. T-Marv
10. Buckson Gooch
11. Speede
12. Crown Jules
13. Finnish Phenom
14. Stefan Raab
17. Rebel

(I forgot to take Donald Deruty off the list after Night 2.)

Day 4 Ends 11:59PM EST Tuesday December 18th.

With 15 Alive, 8 votes make a lynch.

DAY 4 BEGINS NOW!

[tuhoa]

Kaylyn, Jeff is 100% correct about me. And I figured that my "Gooch is being too aggressive" explanation, would explain my vote.

Vote: Gooch

And it still sticks. Gooch is way too aggressive, and has no reason to be so aggressive. He has no information, yet decides to push as hard as anyone in the game. And with you taking his side, I have to wonder why. You could be an innocent townee just playing the game, or BOTH of you could be mafia. I don't know, but I'm not taking any chances, and my vote still sticks.

I'm not "leading a lynch". My vote is simply me expressing my opinion.

[KJE]

See you are voting for gooch and saying the reason for it was a gut feeling.. now you are saying the vote should be obvious. No its not obvious. Either he was shown as scum when you checked him or he wasnt. A GUT feeling is not the reason to make a vote.


L1..... I was roleblocked last night... and everyone knows I was going to go for Jules... so... Do we vote Jules, or do you think he is being set up?

[T-Marv]

Now, my vote is going to seem like a bandwaggon Vote, but it really isn't. Let me explain.

Gooch's explaination of things and huge writeup a couple days ago really raised red flags for me, I kept off of him thinking that I was just reading too much into it. BUt finally having the time to go through and read everthing, Gooch is the only person other than Jules that even stands out the TINIEST bit in terms of scum tells.

I will say that I'm good with a Jules lynch here, but I like Gooch to take the fall most of all.

With that said, we can't sit back and watch as more townies get picked off. It's time to be pro active.

Vote: Gooch

[Buckson Gooch]

I have nothing to report.

All I can say is I am town. My style of play shouldnt be held against me. You guys are going to lynch me and see I am town.

[Level-Two]

L1..... I was roleblocked last night... and everyone knows I was going to go for Jules... so... Do we vote Jules, or do you think he is being set up?

Kay, at this point it's almost too premature to tell. If the watcher was smart, they were on you last night. At the same time, I wouldn't exactly encourage them outing their role because our power role players are dropping like flies. However, if they saw something that could lead us to scum at the end of the day for sure and it's worth the trade off - then come out with it.

The move on you is pretty brazen in general. I don't think the scum would typically make that sort of move with a watcher still in play unless it was out of desperation and it was for a big gain. As in - if Jules is scum, they would NEED him alive. With only three mafia; numbers aren't exactly on their side.

That's my read. You?

[Buckson Gooch]

.why was kje roleblocked?

She questioned Jules.

She is blocked.

Vote: Jules

[T-Marv]

IMO, I think Scum Blocks KJE reguardless last night. She outed her target before hand. Therefore, if she is blocked, her target is suspicious, so it could be a good play on their part to frame somebody.

HOWEVER, if James IS scum, then they'd definately block her cause they knew it would out one of their own, and then they could always play the "James was obviously framed" Card.....

Which, btw, they now can't play.

[KJE]

I honestly don't know...

I didn't hide it at all that I was going for Jules.. everyone was able to see that. The thing is.... I said it from day 1... and night two I was not blocked at all... so honestly I have to think that Jules IS scum... because if he wasn't why wasn't I blocked the night 2? Night 2 we named people that were town it seems and now when it came to last night the only one stated was Jules to look into and I am blocked...

I have to go for it.

Vote Jules

And if I am wrong I am sorry...

I can't jump on the Gooch vote though... something don't seem too right about that... then again with his last reply.. he might be also.. Not quite sure. I guess I will have to hear from more people and watch to see if I will be changing my vote.

[tuhoa]

Dec 16, 2012 2:38:32 GMT -4 Buckson Gooch said:

I have nothing to report.

All I can say is I am town. My style of play shouldnt be held against me. You guys are going to lynch me and see I am town.

Dec 16, 2012 2:41:47 GMT -4 Buckson Gooch said:

.why was kje roleblocked?

She questioned Jules.

She is blocked.

Vote: Jules

Blatant avoidance/passing off. I'm convinced now more than every that you're scum.

PS... Your style of play will ALWAYS be taken into account.

[Buckson Gooch]

Be that as it may, I have been nothing but open. If I have an opinion, I try to justify it. I have been nothing but honest in my plea for being town even asking for people to checK me out.

A vote for me is a vote for a townie. No evidence agakinst me because there is no way there can be...I am town. The gut feeling is wrong. You will all see that I am not scum

[Jules]

Dec 16, 2012 3:46:53 GMT -4 KJE said:

Vote Jules

And if I am wrong I am sorry...

You are wrong. This is a set-up. If you can't see that well then I fear for this town. To have invited investigation and then make a RB that would obviously lead back to me isn't exactly out of the book of great mafia plays. Not saying I'm reading that book, but I neither am I that naive.

Vote: Buckson Gooch

This set-up stinks of a rookie move. I thought I'd do some digging on A.C. last night, but unfortunately I wasn't given the help I needed on that front. I'm still not sure about that guy, but Gooch's behaviour during the last day and the immediate vote on me based on his interpretation of events smacks of someone pushing too hard for his own set-up.

[Jules]

Dec 16, 2012 2:45:52 GMT -4 T-Marv said:

IMO, I think Scum Blocks KJE reguardless last night. She outed her target before hand. Therefore, if she is blocked, her target is suspicious, so it could be a good play on their part to frame somebody.

HOWEVER, if James IS scum, then they'd definately block her cause they knew it would out one of their own, and then they could always play the "James was obviously framed" Card.....

Which, btw, they now can't play.

I assume you mean 'Jules' by 'James'. Anyway, this has raised an eyebrow with me. When are you ever this cautious, Marv? Not saying that means anything right now, but it just doesn't sit that well with me.

[Buckson Gooch]

Yeah, Tmarv, how dare you even remotely think Jules suspect behavior is...suspect. You voted for me, but your hint of wonder on Jules raises eyebrows.

Looks like we will know who the next bandwagon lynching will be for.

Tmarv, you had better not mention Phenom either or the scu...I mean the obviously town Jules and Phenom will get upset.

[President Jeff]

Rebel and Mark Mania both had 1 post during day 3. Now I'm not saying they are scum, But they aren't adding anything, thus almost being forgotten in the game. Could be their way of flying under the radar of picking people off?

Maybe something to think about

Also, Tmarv, James V, Level One, Jules all strong mafia players yet their all still alive. Seems odd to me that Mafia would kill Chris Hart and Callahan when those two haven't really done anything that seemed like a threat.

[Mark Mania]

Sorry about that, not one post to avoid, one post because it was a hectic week.

I'm battling back in forth in my head about this Jules vote. On one hand I understand why the scum would block KJE and then make it look like it was to protect Jules. The only reason I could see them doing this is if Jules is the killer for the mafia, aside from that it looks like he's town and beig set up. I really can't tell yet.

I want to see more people check in but my vote will either be for Gooch or Jules. We need to make something happen this Day.

[SalTal]

Checking in. The Jules vote ... I'm just not sold on it. I usually need something tangible to link all the circumstantial. Until we get something tangible, I don't think I can readily vote for him.

Gooch, well, I just don't know his style. I think he is town, given that a new player being scum would be a little more telling.