Branden Harvey's a Bastard Mafia Game Thread

[brandenharvey]

Vote Count:

Stephan Hart: 3 (“Simply Put” Johnny Rebel, CJ Gates, Stephan Hart)

Deadline is midnight on Saturday.

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

[Stephan Hart]

Not even an insane accusation, but Scum. My God! Rebel what would you say when I turn up as the Town cop?

I'm curious and give me a straight and honest answer since you're not scum.

Also you won't have to bother about me for much longer. Cause as of July 25th, I'll be in Aruba and doubt I'll even be able to continue to play this game. Will be working for two weeks. so you get your wish one way or the other. The mod will either kill me off (if I'm not lynched or dead by the end of the 2nd night) or replace me, with somebody who will maybe play the game differently, but will pretty much have the same role.......Town Cop.

[Stephan Hart]

Will probably be back the 2nd week of August. So that's longer than two weeks.

[C.J. Gates]

A quick little jot while on my break.

To Hart: I said I didn't know 100% if you were scum, but that you were the scummiest on Day One. Day Two came and you jumped down my neck. I voted for you because you still seemed scummy, especially since you are voting for a townie on misinformation. Am I still thinking you're scummy? I'm probably leaning more toward insane cop at this point because that's the ONLY way that you would get a guilty on me because I AM TOWN.

To Lester: Hart COULD be a cop, either mafia or town. If there are three Mafia, there's obviously a Godfather, Hitman and then a roleblocker or a cop, one of those two. Hart could be claiming Cop if he was given safe claims or something and who knows, maybe he IS scum and is being fed the info to use from other scum. That's the only reason my vote will remain on him right now.

As far as J-Reb or SalTal goes, I can't say. I'm going to give the whole thread a read over when I get home and decide from there.

[Stephan Hart]

Since it really makes no sense for me to continue this game. I'm leaving Monday anyways. Mr. Moderator, can I be Mod killed and prove these clowns I'm not a Scum and get the game moving forward?

Would be interested to see their sudden shock, awe and surprise when I turn up to be a Townie and they was like WRONG. I admit I could be insane, but that's not enough for some clowns. Elimination is best, Mod Kill actually would be fine even better.

Although I won't be able to participate when I'm done for, I personally would like to hear what the so called righteous have to say about the death of a Town Cop (possible insane, but not Mafia). I already damaged the character for anybody to take over to be honest, so let's see the real answer.

With all that was said according to CJ and Rebel, I suppose to be Mafia. So results should state I am Mafia. and no cheating Mr. Moderator. No cheating. lol

[brandenharvey]

I'm going to give you two hours to reconsider. If you still want to be modkilled, I'll do it.

[Stephan Hart]

Yay! One more hour.

Nice how everyone suddenly goes quiet, when they hear a mod kill is in two hours. Probably wondering if I will let it go. Why would I reconsider. I'm innocent of not being a scum.

LOL laughing at those who are so confident that I am not a cop, but working for the mafia. Because after this I won't have time to laugh. so Roflmao! lol

Once again keep eyes on SalTal, Rebel and CJ (CJ is def scum if I turn up to be perfectly sane.)

Unfortunately I won't be able to see the potential end of this game or even follow it to my fullest as of July 25th. My job require me to be stationed in Aruba for couple weeks or so.

Good Luck Townies!

Screw You Scumbags!

corrected an 'if' to an 'is'. My time is about up shouldn't be a big deal I hope with modifying.

[C.J. Gates]

Here is what I've gathered, and yes, it doesn't clear anything up.

I am beginning to believe Hart is less and less scum. If he is as new as he says he is, it could just be that age old factor of the new guy getting jumpy. If he indeed is an insane cop as I believe him to be, he might also realize he has a power role and doesn't want to be gone. Will it matter if he's getting modkilled? No, but regardless.

Unvote

No, Hart, it's not because I'm flip-flopping it's because I'm beginning to see you more as an inexperienced player who was unaware of the usual safe bet that cops should check themselves on night one to make sure that their intel will be useful.

And as for the rest.

@ Lester: You mentioned early on in day 2, that you figured they targeted Blade or Jeff. Any way you knew? I know you said your own detective reasonings, just wondering how you came to that conclusion.

Sally: She did get kind of quiet after Hart began his little rant, and I'd be inclined to FOS her. That post was also a bit out of the way, but as we all saw with her OOC word limit post, it might just be a joke.

J-Reb: He seems to be claiming more of a watcher role than cop. A watcher would see that Hart visited whomever was the target, but wouldn't give a definite guilty verdict. However, this is assuming Hart actually visited the target and not me like Hart claims. He did mention it after Hart ranted a bit, so who knows if he is true or if he just found an opening and went for it like Lester mentioned.

[Stephan Hart]

NOTE: There is one other guy I believe that is suspicious. but you know what? Go figure it out yourselves. And no it's not Ebirah.

[C.J. Gates]

Jeff: He got a bit quiet...I would have assumed he'd be more talkative.

Blade/JD/JC: Are all kind of here and there. If we want to assume Scum are flying under the radar because of Hart's...well, outgoing personality, then maybe these guys should be looked at.

Ebirah: Something didn't sit right with how he restated suspicion of Hart on day one and didn't vote, and then how during the whole thing of day two, he hasn't mentioned it. He could just believe Hart is town but it doesn't exactly sit well.

Hart: Like I said, I'm thinking he's more insane town cop than scum. If he's a jester, he didn't exactly do himself any favors now that it's out there, which MIGHT explain why he's more inclined to be modkilled, although with his trip, it could just be that. And as Lester said, check someone (if you remain) that is 100% scum in your eyes, like you say Sally is. That way if she comes back town, you know you're insane and we all know she's scum. It also clears me as being the town that I DEFINITELY AM. I don't know how many more times I can say that I am 100% town.

Doctor: Whomever is the doctor, protect Hart if he isn't modkilled.

Did I miss anyone?

Harvey: Bastard....

And we're all quiet because we probably don't have the ability to sit on a forum and post repeatedly...just sayin'

[Stephan Hart]

@ - And we're all quiet because we probably don't have the ability to sit on a forum and post repeatedly...just sayin'
-----------------

You're right because I don't have a normal job. lol I get a lot of free time. But when I start working I have zero time for myself.

[Stephan Hart]

Just for the record. From now on when I a playing this game I will no longer call people scum, or mafia, or scumbags no more I got a new name that I've bee realy wanting to call people with a conspiracy to screw up other.

From now on I'll be calling all the Mafia scums, LITTLE JIMMY! I just have to I can't help myself with that one.

edit: Btw, what the hell is a Jester suppose to do? Just curious and wondering.

[C.J. Gates]

Jester, from my understanding, is a role that wins the game when they are lynched. They can be modkilled and night killed no problem but if they're lynched they fulfill their win condition and will win the game at the end.

I think. I'm not 100% sure though that's what I've gathered.

[brandenharvey]

Okay, guys. Here goes:

Stephan Hart is walking down the street, muttering to himself. He sees CJ Gates, his suspect, and runs after him. As he runs, his feet are no longer working on the ground. He seems to be falling. he comes to his senses and realizes he had run after someone that wasn't there... and ran off the side of a thirty story building. He starts thinking that maybe...

SPLAT!

DEAD - Stephan Hart - Town Insane Cop

Night starts now. I'm giving you a little longer this time, due to me not being able to get online until this time.

Night ends at midnight Saturday.

Get your night actions in to me.

[Level-Two]

Lynch Rebel.

Doctor protect me.

Am I breaking the rules? Fuck it. That mod kill shit out of nowhere, sucks.

[brandenharvey]

*smacks L1's hand* No talking at night.

Jul 22, 2011 18:33:58 GMT -4 Level-Two said:

That mod kill shit out of nowhere, sucks.

I agree. But what was I supposed to say? No? When someone tells me they no longer want to play my game, I'm not going to force them.

[Blade]

vote Jonny Rebel

He has info that Hart was scum, it is obvious he wasnt. 2 insane cops? I doubt it

[brandenharvey]

*smacks Blade's hand* No talking at night.

[brandenharvey]

DEADLINE!!

The Mafia gathered and argued. They couldn't agree who to kill. They left it at no one.

No night kill.

Day ends at midnight Monday.

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

GO!

[Level-Two]

Interesting that the mafia forgot to send in their nightkill.

This obviously leads to two suspects as MAFIA Godfather. T- Marv or JD Storm. I'm leaning towards JD Storm because I don't see how a veteran player like T- Marv makes such a amateur mistake. Did anyone see T-Marv online earlier today?

However with that said, we can put put those two names on the backburner because I think we have a clear scum already pin pointed out.

Vote: Johnny Rebel

Buh-bye, scummer.

[SalTal]

I saw TMarv on recently. Not too sure at what time in reference to your time zone, but I know it was in the past 24 hours.

Now, in saying that I've been thinking. Blade tried a game with all scum. Branden gets an idea to do something real upside down and goes with a game of all Town. I mean, let's look at it: Two night phases and two non-kills. Ok, so the first I can understand if it was me. But the second? The Scum couldn't get together on it? Or forgot to send anything in? That's out there; not impossible, but out there.

Some other additional stuff: I know I'm Town, we know CJ is Town, and Hart turns up insane cop (not Scum). Obviously there has to be a lot of Town in the game, but it's starting to weight up.

Plus, that would make it a real bastard game.

I'll also throw this out: I went quiet after the past couple of days because today is Sunday. The past two days were Friday and Saturday. I went out after work on Friday, woke up late on Saturday, worked on my Experts promo in the afternoon, then went out again last night. I stayed quiet for most of today because it was night.

I didn't try extra hard to get some posts up because Hart was giving me a headache. Feeding the fire was not helping. I mean, if he was listening to what people were saying, he might have calmed down and we could make head or tail of what he was saying. I was hoping he'd slow down and thinking about this, laying out some serious arguments that were detailed and coherent rather than ellusive and alluding.

I was wrong, obviously. But he served his purpose, because he said he had info on CJ, which worked for all of us to prove that CJ was Town. Rebel said he has information that CJ wasn't. Rebel is wrong. Therefore I expect the votes to pile up on Rebel. I'll be your last vote, Rebel, if I get in.

By all means explain yourself. I won't vote until the last, and I want to hear what you had/have to say.

I also what to know what some other role-people dug up at night.

[Level-Two]

Blade did a game where everyone was a serial killer or something. If everyone is Town; then nobody dies during the night and this game could potentially never end if no one ever agrees on the lynches. And then why lynch anyone in the first place, if we're all townies?

I just don't see the point even though you have an interesting view on the game.

[Michael Jennings]

Very interesting indeed. Sounds like someone who isn't really active or hasn't been online as much is the Godfather which narrows down the list. Before I vote for Rebel, who is the obvious choice right now, I'd like to hear from him first before doing any voting to hear his perspective on things.

[SalTal]

It was just a speculation. We wouldn't know we're all Town, I imagine that would have been the whole point of making us all Town - to see who we turn on.

If we find a scum then obviously that whole theory is shot. I imagine what turns up on Rebel might have something. If he turns up with one of those whacky roles where he got strange information then I'll be even more sceptical that there's any scum here.

But, as we've got the most suspicion on Rebel we might as well ask him for information on himself. Why did he think CJ was scum and all.

[T-Marv]

I appologize for not being active. I'm back and I'm better to play now.
Also I did send in a night action and I got a very fucked up result.

Does anybody know why a player would visit somebody who's already dead?

[C.J. Gates]

Rebel didn't think I was scum Sally. Rebel said that he knew Hart had something to do with the attempted kill on night one. But with Hart saying he investigated me, and came up cop, that shows that Hart most likely did target me that night, and therefore Rebel's claim that Hart was involved in the kill wouldn't make sense.

Vote: Rebel

If there are 3-4 scum, there would be 8-9 town. I don't think Harvey would do an all town game. I mean, the first post he made to start the game said the original godfather was dead, and a new godfather had stepped up...

[C.J. Gates]

EBWOP

Went back and found the quote from Rebel.

Jul 22, 2011 8:27:14 GMT -4 Johnny Rebel said:

This one is as obvious as can be. I advocated waiting for the night to see if any information came up and while we didn't get any from a lynch, I happen to know for sure that Hart was involved in the attempted murder last night.

I understand defending yourself but his antics have been over the line.

I purposely have not said a whole lot because I meant it when I said I was waiting for information before I made a move. I have all of the information I need.

[Blade]

Jul 24, 2011 9:30:22 GMT -4 T-Marv said:

I appologize for not being active. I'm back and I'm better to play now.
Also I did send in a night action and I got a very fucked up result.

Does anybody know why a player would visit somebody who's already dead?

Not unless it was a modified role that Branden has made up.



Anyway, now its day again

Vote: Rebel

He was adamant Hart was scum, he turned up town. Somehow I dont see both Hart and Rebel being both paranoid/insane whatever it was.

He said he had the info and that woudl lead to a scum lynch. it didnt.

[Kurt]

This is such a weird game, ha.

I agree with L1's reasoning that the lack of a night kill puts a bit of suspicion on JD or Tmarv. I need to see Tmarv or JD (maybe he has a silent role of some sort?) post a bit more. And judging by the way the write-up is, it doesn't seem like the scum were roleblocked (can scum be roleblocked?), if I'm understanding how that works correctly.

Obviously, the focus is on Rebel now. Before I throw my vote in the ring though, I want to see his explanation. He was certain that Hart was scum, and I believed his investigation...but now that's turned out to be false.

But we need a lynch today. There have been no nightkills or lynches yet, minus the modkill. We can only count on getting lucky at night so many times.

So what's the deal Rebel?

[brandenharvey]

Vote Count:

"Simply Put" Johnny Rebel: 3 (Lester "L1" Only, Blade, CJ Gates)

Day ends at midnight Monday.

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.