South Park Mafia Game Thread

[Nova]

I still don't know if I want to jump on the lynch Harvey bus. I just don't want to kill potential townies via lynching. Sure there are a lot of us, but every time one of our own gets lynched we get closer to losing the game. Perhaps we can find someone else with better reasoning besides: "His name is Harvey and he is awkward." To be honest this is how Harvey always plays...its him being extremely obvious and always trying to come off town, most of the time so far he has been a town when he does this. If he started not acting the way he usually acts, then I would be all for lynching him, but for now...I just don't know.

[Jason Cashe]

I'm sorry about the Post Edit, NEW to this game. Slap on the wrist and I know better. Carry on. Still Harvey in my opinion. If he turns out to be a townie then whats one less of those right? Hahaha...Just a gut feeling and even when I'm high I feel it's him so I can't be wrong...can I?

[President Jeff]

Deadline is tonight guys, Why is no one talking?

[brandenharvey]

We need to lynch someone today to learn something. If that person is me, lynch me. When you learn I'm town, go after L1 and/or Kash.

Or, and I like this one better, lynch L1 and if he's town, lynch me.

[brandenharvey]

Vote: Lester "L1" Only

[Jason Cashe]

Or lynch you Harvey and then worry about who is lynched next.

[C.J. Gates]

I truly don't think anyone will get lynched at this point in time, which might be for the best. We don't really have anything to go off of right now, so maybe some information can be uncovered with night roles that will help us out in day three.

[Michael Jennings]

People, wake up. If this town wants to shoot itself in the foot that's fine but there's no way that there should be this much inactivity in a game.

[Level-Two]

Scum probably would have jumped on the vote at this point. Unless, scum already has their votes on Harvey, it`s probably because Harvey himself is scum.

Whatever, let`s just not lynch anyone all game. That`s a sure fire way to win! We`re probably going to lose one or two people from mod kills, btw.

[President Jeff]

Day 2 ends with a NO LYNCH

Night 2 Begins. No talking allowed. You have 24 hours to send me your night action

[President Jeff]

In Cartman’s Basement is Butters and Cartman are playing The Sega Dreamcast while Craig is watching them.

Butters: Gee Eric, this is a lot of fun.

Cartman: Yeah, the new Mortal Kombat is kick ass.

Craig: When can I have my turn.

Cartman: Craig, I already told you, you can have a turn once Butters beats me.

Cuts to the TV screen and a Fatality happens

Cartman: Wow Butters, I totally kicked your ass

Butter: Yah Eric, your Awesome at this.


KNOCK KNOCK KNOCK


Cartman: MOM, GETS THE DOOR!

We cut updates to Eric’s mom opening the door and standing there is Officer Barbrady

Officer Barbrady: Hello Miss Cartman.

Liane: Oh, Hello Mr. Barbrady. You’re a couple days early for our weekly get together.

Officer Barbrady: No, I’m not here for that. I am going around asking people for Information on the Mafia.

Liane: I don’t have any information officer, Maybe Eric does. He’s down stairs playing with his little friends.

Officer Barbrady: Ok, I’ll go talk to him.

Scene cuts to Cartman’s basement where Butters and Cartman are still playing Video games with Craig watching. Barbrady comes down the stairs and the boys stop playing

Officer Barbrady: Hello boys, I was wondering if you guys know anything about the mafia.

Cartman: No

Craig: No

Butters: Gee Golly, I sure don’t officer.

Cartman: Hey, cool, is that a real gun?

Officer Barbrady: It sure is.

Cartman: Can I hold it. I promise not to shoot it.

Officer Barbrady: Ok, I see no harm in that.

He hands Cartman the gun and he looks at it

Cartman: Here Butters, check this out!

Cartman tosses it to Butters. Butters catches it but accidently pulls the trigger and shoots Officer Barbrady in he head, killing him.

Butter: Oh Hamburgers!

Cartman: Damn Butters, I didn’t know you had it in you

Craig: That’s bad ass Butters.

Scene cuts to a new Report with the reporter standing outside Cartmans house, Interviewing Butters Parents with Butters standing beside them.

Linda: I don’t know what gotten into our son to do such a thing

Stephan: When we get home, Butters will be grounded for a month

Butters: Does that mean that we won’t be going to Bennigan’s tomorrow?

Stephan: If you keep it up mister, you’ll never go to Bennigan’s again.

*****

Dead: Jason Kash


Note: With Sally MIA, she is being Replaced with Terry Marvin. Terry will be taking over Sally’s role.


11 Alive, Takes 6 Votes to Lynch

Deadline: Thursday @ 9pm EST

Not Voting: Blade, Level One, Branden, Stephan Hart, CJ, Johnny Rebel, Ebirah, Nobel, Biggs, Pence, Tmarv


Day 3 Now Begins

[Stephan Hart]

First of all we really need to lynch somebody or else we're going to lose. the Mafia has had a head start of two night kills and we haven't done anything yet.

Now for the last round I unvoted for Harvey, because of his claim. Which I'm going to say I don't know for one hundred percent if he's telling the truth or just made it up.

Remember this?

I'm town. I'm also telling you this game could be over on day three. Lynch L1 on day one, JC on day two, and Kash on day three. Game over.

Well so far both JC and Kash have been killed by The Mafia.

I know he said it was a gut feeling and all. But two people on your list in a row. Maybe the Mafia is framing you as JamesV said or maybe it's all a diabolical plot. We need to start making tough decisions in this or else we're not going to reach anywhere and it'll be too late later on. The Mafia is either hiding behind you or you are on of the members. Either way you got to go so the town could at least start getting a lead. because second day in the game, nine pages of posts and we have reached no where. the Mafia is picking us off one by one.

Vote: Harvey

I actually have another theory, bu I refuse to say it now. Because it'll just confuse people and then we'll be back to square one, where less than a hand full votes for one person and less than a hand full votes for the other person and we'll be stuck with not enough votes to lynch by the end of the day.

NOTE: Even though I did re-voted or kept my vote on Harvey the last round, we needed 7 votes, we only had 6 through out the game day.

[Kurt]

What a ridiculous day phrase.

Alright guys, here's things from my point of view: We either lynch Harvey now and risk ending the game...or just dilly dally, get no consensus, and get picked off one by one until the game's over. It's Day 3, and we have no information whatsoever from night actions...so more playing blind. We didn't vote the last day phase, which is a really bad sign in my opinion. We all (myself included) need to be more active, so let's get on that.

Focus is still on Harvey, and we all know that. He's just going to keep throwing wrenches in the deductions, even if we look toward someone else. He's still gonna be nagging us in the back of our minds...so I say we risk it. Or at least, someone needs to come up with something night-wise.

Or we could just lynch L1 and lose our most active player and twiddle our thumbs until we lose. Not really a fan of that option, to be honest.

Vote: Branden Harvey

[C.J. Gates]

I'd have to agree with Noble. The only lead we have is Harvey, and with nothing else having been brought out yet, there's not much else we can go on. Like Noble said, we have to do something to try and get some information, even if lynching Harvey is a risky move.

Vote: Branden Harvey

It is still early in day three, though, so people could still be checking in for their night results. Hopefully someone has something that can give us a concrete lead so we aren't just sitting around.

[Johnny Rebel]

I agree, Noble. The only word to describe this game so far is ridiculous. I can't get a read on Harvey yet -- his game play is so strung out, it's hard to tell what the deal is. Out of his top three, two are dead (look out L1). He's either playing sloppy himself or we're just overlooking him because it seems too obvious to be true.

The other option is that the Mafia is being incredibly sloppy in their gameplay. It seems too easy to frame Harvey because he's picked out his targets and has stuck to them. That makes me believe that whoever is scum is new to the game and is taking the safe route at this point.

The only thing we know at this point is that two out of the three people Harvey targeted are dead and he has no defense.

Vote: Harvey

[brandenharvey]

Vote: Lester "L1" Only

Probably a moot vote. The blood of Christ will be on all your hands.

[President Jeff]

Vote Count

Branden - 4
Level One - 1

Not Voting: Level One, Ebirah, Biggs, Pence, Tmarv, Blade

11 Alive, takes 6 to Lynch

Deadline on Thursday @ 9pm EST

[Level-Two]

So, before I put my vote on Harvey to lynch him; why if you're a town river, didn't you revive anyone during night phase? Secondly, why do you think Mafia didn't kill you?

If you're town, surely you can come up with a reasonable explanation.

[Level-Two]

EWOP

And Jeff, can you please clarify who Jason Kash was? Vanilla Townie?

[brandenharvey]

I protected somebody both nights. But those people weren't targeted. As for why Mafia hasn't targetted me, probably so they can frame me. Why don't you tell me, L1?

Kash was obviously Officer Barbrady. That would probably make him a cop.

[T-Marv]

Here I come to save the day!!!!

Alright, I looked over day 2 and I'm still forming my thoughts. Let me say first of all, i think everybody might be on the wrong page with Branden. I think you're going way too hard on Branden... he is almost clearly being framed (though I could be wrong.) I'm not saying he's definately not scum, but it's almost TOO easy. Get back to you when I read more.

[Level-Two]

Aug 15, 2011 21:31:27 GMT -4 @brandenharvey said:

I protected somebody both nights. But those people weren't targeted. As for why Mafia hasn't targetted me, probably so they can frame me. Why don't you tell me, L1?

Reviver's BRING back dead people to the game. Yet, you say you ''protected somebody'' both nights. In other words, your lying.

Vote: Branden Harvey

[Johnny Rebel]

Aug 15, 2011 19:06:19 GMT -4 Stephan Hart said:

I actually have another theory, bu I refuse to say it now. Because it'll just confuse people and then we'll be back to square one, where less than a hand full votes for one person and less than a hand full votes for the other person and we'll be stuck with not enough votes to lynch by the end of the day.

With nothing else to go on, if you have something new to offer, please--by all means--share it!

[Kurt]

Yeah, before the final vote is thrown in, if anyone has ANYTHING to share...better do it now.

Let's see if anyone tries to stop that from happening.

[biggs]

Vote: Branden Harvey

S-s-s-same reason as before.

What's a sh-shar-SHAR-shark's favorite illegal substance?

R-R-R-Reefer!

[Michael Jennings]

Oh look, Harvey's already lynched. Not surprising. Also I agree with everything Tmarv said. Hit the nail right on the head. I'll be interested to see Harvey's alignment.

[Stephan Hart]

I'm going to take some advice posted on here and post my theory.

There is a possibility that Harvey is not scum, but should that be a reason why the Town does no come together and lynch him. I think Harvey messed himself up mainly when he predicted his gut feeling and said L1, Kash and JC (I believe) was scum and we should get rid of them. he said it because he had a gut feeling and now he's paying for it, because at least half of the players looks at him suspicious. I think it's best we get raid of that problem and then carry our focus else where. Yes there is a high a 50% chance he could turn up townie. if he does, guess what? The mafia will have to use somebody else to hide behind.

Now there here is my theory.

What if Harvey is not Mafia. What if the Mafia wants to keep Harvey around as long as possible, so the town could focus on him while they take us out one by one.

I think there is a possibility that among those who is accusing Harvey, the Mafia has one implant in the mix to keep the heat on Harvey. Meanwhile the Mafia themselves protect him and stand up for him and make sure they confuse us just enough so we do not lynch him. I don't think the Mafia wants Harvey gone from this game. All the heat on him working towards their advantage, while we can't eliminate him, because the Mafia who could easily put one vote in and get rid of him is not doing so. So we will go on day in and day out not pointing fingers at Harvey, bu not getting enough votes to lynch him. Night times come and they eliminate somebody else, they stick with the list of suspected scum that Harvey put out which I now think was a stupid move by Harvey, so we could look at him and say he's suspicious one way or the other.

Yes JamesV is correct, Harvey is being set up by the mafia and it is JamesV and another Mafia member job to make sure Harvey is not eliminated. while somebody among us who is pointing finger at Harvey is also a mafia.

Currently we have the 6 votes I believe to eliminate Harvey, quite frankly, JamesV might be a little upset this happened so fast, but it does not bother him one bit, because he's knows Harvey is was set up and by night time another one of us will be killed.

When Harvey shows up as town, JamesV will be there to say I told you so. automatically we will start to rethink or position and we will not even look at JamesV as a suspect. I think JamesV is MAFIA and not Harvey.

Quite frankly we need to take our focus off of Harvey, forget about him and focus on the guys played this game masterful. I not sure who's the other two, but I am positive from what I've read and my theory that jamesV who's been by the side of Harvey from day one is not his friend, but is one of the master minds that is setting him up. note Harvey wouldn't even look at him as a Mafia, because he's one of maybe two or the only person that is clearly standing by Harvey.

the Mafia is using common sense against us. we look at the situation, do we really believe that the Mafia will make it so easy to take out one of their own? What I'm trying to say is that we will look at Harvey and say the evidence is so overwhelming, that he would want us to think it's that easy in hopes we don't vote for him, so we vote for him. What if it really is too easy? And the Mafia wants us to think the way we are currently thinking and that is it's so easy, something is up get rid of him.

Yes the mafia is probably trying to keep Harvey in the game, but right now we have enough votes. Would that hurt the Mafia? No, not if he shows up as a Townie.

I'll keep my vote for now, but yes keep eyes on JamesV.

[Stephan Hart]

We have enough time to debate. If nothing changes I bring back vote with the majority. As of right now I

Unvote: Harvey

Let's debate! Keep an eye on Harvey, focus on JamesV.

[Level-Two]

Harvey's already lynched, SH. Oddly enough, you typed up everything I was thinking in the event Harvey turns up town. Ebriah has been persistent in claiming Branden Harvey isn't scum; despite the overwhelming signs pointing to him. He's defended him almost like a scum buddy and has taken a ''I told you so'' approach before the lynch has even happened. It's odd.

I also feel that I've been somewhat set to take a fall as well based on who's been killed thus far but I won't get into it. All I know is, if I'm not night killed; expect the lynch wagon to turn my way.

[Stephan Hart]

oh okay thanks for letting me know, guess my unvote does not count.
I doubt they'll take you out during the night hours L1. why? Because you'll be the obvious target in the next round, to them you'll probably be an easy/free Lynch, while they could take out somebody else. hell I won't be surprise if they come after me.

However if they read this, their strategy might change. If that is the case, then yeah I'm pretty close to figuring this puzzle out.

FOR THOSE WHO SURVIVE THE NIGHT KILL

Take out James V next round. Something is up with this guy and you know he'll come up with something to say and tr focus on somebody else, likely receiving back up by his Mafia buddies. I don't have solid investigative proof, but from the way this game have been played out, something is up with JamesV.

Remember there is probably one among us, agreeing with everything we do.

And then there is the quiet one.

Focus on JamesV no matter what.