South Park Mafia Game Thread

[President Jeff]

Lester, Jason Kash was a Town Member. Figured you get that with the Write up and his name in Green.


AND THATS A LYNCH!

Sorry Stephan, once the votes are in for a Lynch, can't take your vote back

I'll tie in Branden's Lynch into the write up for the Night Kill

Day 3 Ends

Night 3 Begins

I'd like to get Day 4 Started back up by tonight, so please get all night actions into me by 9pm EST

[President Jeff]

Day 3

Scene opens up to the talk show, Jesus and pals

Jesus: Hello, welcome to Jesus and friends. Today’s show, we will be talking about the Mafia that is in South Park and has been killing innocent people for the last two night. If anybody has any information, please call us.

Ok we have a caller. Do you have any information my child

Voice: Wooooo, JESUS YOU ROCK!!

Jesus: Thank you my child.

Just then, the town of South Park barge into the Studio being led by Jimbo and Ned, with Ned holding an AK-47.

Jimbo: Hey Jesus, we Believe that you’re the one behind the mafia for what the jews did to you in the Passion of the Christ

Jesus: Your just upset that my ratings are better than your little hunting show.

Just then, Stan shows up.

Stan: Uncle Jimbo, Jesus is innocent. He can’t be part of the mafia.

Jesus stands up.

Jimbo: Get him Ned, He’s coming Straight for us!

Ned begins shooting Jesus and kills him.

Stan: Holy Shit dude!

A doctor randomly shows up and checks on Jesus

Doctor: He’s…..He’s a Townie!


Dead: Branden Harvey - Jesus, Town Healer/Doctor


Night 3

Scene opens to Randy Marsh in his basement on the computer

Randy: Oh man, my farm is so kick ass. I’m going to plant some corn over here and some water mellon over there….Damnit, I need more friends.

STAN, ACCEPT MY FRIEND REQUEST FOR FARMVILLE!

Just then the basement door opens slowly

Randy: Stan?

Randy turns aroud, but a dark figure is all he see’s

Randy: Sharron?

Just then the dark Shadow turns into Cartman holding a knife

Cartman: Sorry Mr. Marsh, Your time is now

Randy: NO…NO…NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!

Cartman stabs Randy to death before leaving through the Basement Window.


Dead: Ebirah, Townie


Day 4 Now Begins

9 Alive, it takes 5 Votes to Lynch

Deadline is Friday Night @ 9pm EST

[Stephan Hart]

Wow! There goes my theory down the toilet about JamesV.

Not shocked with who Harvey turned out to be, but I'm stunned with who JamesV turned out to be.

We really need to look at the situation, cause this is all messed up.

[President Jeff]

C'mon guys. Its been almost 24 hours since day 4 began and only 1 person has posted anything

[Level-Two]

Well, I was waiting to see how people would respond after yet another blatant attempt to frame me (maybe SH too). In regards to the Harvey's death, I take some blame but he could have defended himself a hell of a lot better and never claimed he was a doctor. So, when he said he was a reviver protecting people, I thought he was lying.

JamesV was shocking to me. Mafia is clearly has an experienced player on their side. I think it's time we break this stupid pattern on lynching the most active players ready to speak up ever day phase and lynch a quiet one.

To me, Blade is highly suspicious. He's playing the same way he did last game when he was scum. Low profile, posts just enough to keep under the radar and never really helps town. Also, his beginning spatter with Harvey I always found to be odd. I understand naturally I am going to be the next in line for a lynch waggon but if that's the way it goes, it's going to do much more harm then good.

[biggs]

W-Well that just sucked! I agree with L-L-Level-One that Branden screwed the pooch with his defense.

Still, one thing that sticks out about Lester's post is that he said Mafia has an experienced player on their side. On one hand, I want to hear a defense from Blade, because I think Lester made a good point, b-b-but I also think it might be a good defense on Lester's part to throw out the experienced claim. F-fact is, if we're wrong tonight, it's pretty much g-g-game over!

W-Why was Cinderell-ell-ELL-ella kicked off the Softball team?

Because she ran away from the b-b-buh-BUH-ball!

[C.J. Gates]

Aug 17, 2011 18:36:04 GMT -4 Level-Two said:

In regards to the Harvey's death, I take some blame but he could have defended himself a hell of a lot better and never claimed he was a doctor. So, when he said he was a reviver protecting people, I thought he was lying.

I thought he was lying because he role claimed his character and role, and didn't get lynched, even though the rules say no role claiming at all. I guess he had enough votes when he did, but I assumed he was lying because he didn't get mod killed.

Blade could be one to hear from and see what he has to say. I was hoping that some people to still check in this day might have some intel to help point us in the right direction as well.

[Level-Two]

Well here's two more things on my mind:

1) Blade had claimed day one that he had a ''powerful role'' that would help town and would have his town status claimed sooner rather then later; this of course, only if we didn't lynch him day one when people (mainly James V) were suspicious of him. Well, we're getting down to the wire and now about's time you spill your guts and help us out.

2) This one is mainly just an observation. Blade has been offline since the recent drought of posts. I'm not trying to sweep anyone under the rug here and this is just a theory; but maybe Blade is directing the strategy for MAFIA's gameplan and their waiting on him to give further directions.

[President Jeff]

Just a FYI, Blade is taking a break from APW due to his health. He said he would still try to play though. If he can't, might just replace him instead of Mod Killing him. Just waiting on a reply PM from him

[T-Marv]

I stated last day that Branden was a bad lynch. Something just didn't feel right about it. We can't afford to do that again guys.

JamesV would have been my first Goto guy for the lynch today. Without that, I'm thinking we need a break. Anybody?

[Kurt]

What are we missing here guys?

Alright, so assuming our cop is dead, looks like the only way we're going to find scum is just through good old looking. I agree with L1's approach that we don't necessarily need to attempt to lynch the most active player(s) because they typically just turn out to be fighting townspeople. Scum like to hide under the radar and basically try and agree with the general consensus. They don't generally attempt to go against it, I think.

So who over the past few days has been:

A. Not too active, but not inactive.
B. Agreeing to a general consensus without much of a discussion.
C. Not bringing too many new points into the game.

I don't think JamesV is scum, nor is L1. They've both been too active and have had too much discussion between them and others. So that pretty much leaves...well, everybody else, ha.

I assume no one has anything noteworthy to share from Night actions, right?

[Nova]

I don't know where to turn right now...I don't know if I can trust Lester or anyone for that matter. Blade sounds like a good choice and since we are so far behind in terms of finding the scum we need to find one before deadline comes or all our gooses are pretty much cooked. Now, we could go with Blade, definitely a good choice, but is that the only choice we can make. We lost two town rather quickly and it is imperative if we make our move it has to be the best damned move we can make. So, is Blade our only option?

[Level-Two]

Well, we can lynch Blade or we can wait to see who he's replaced with. The only problem is; that in the event he's scum, the person stepping in is now an active scum.

[T-Marv]

Well, one thing's for sure...we can rule out blade as GF....he hasn't been around yet there've been kills. He may be scum but the chances are dwindling.

If we take him out now...we most likely get a townie. I say we delve in a little deeper. Who was the lead on the brandon lynch? Who was the hammer? Take them and disect them.

[Level-Two]

Good points about Blade Tmarv. I was the lead on the branden lynch. Stephan Hart was the hammer. I have no qualms with admitting I lead the charge on Harvey. I had my reasons. I'd personally look at those who jumped on the bandwagon with the least amount of input while doing so.

If we want to lynch an inactive, Nova is next in line when it comes to not doing much for town either way. Sorry, dude. With that said, I'm not quite sure he's scum either.

As far as active players, CJ Gates stands out to me. If anyone as any more investigative roles in this game, I'd recommend you check him out to at least clear him or something. I don't have any core proof to put a vote on him so I'm not going to go there right now but he's certainly playing a different game from what I have seen in the past--if it's because he's scum or just because he doesn't want to be killed off by mafia for being a threat early, something is different.

[Johnny Rebel]

I think the finger needs to be pointed at L1 here.

It started off with Harvey listing off those who he thought was scum. He wanted L1 dead initially which isn't out of the norm for him so we ignored it. He also listed JC and Kash as possible scum. What's ironic is that the first two to turn up dead are Kash and JC, leading to a Harvey lynch. At the time we were thinking Harvey was just playing the obvious game and picking off the people he had called off -- but what if meanwhile L1 was just framing Harvey and taking people off his list to take the heat off himself?

That's the only thing I have to go of off at this point. I believe L1 is scum and has been playing us all this whole time.

VOTE L1

[C.J. Gates]

So I went back and took a look to try and find something and after doing so, I think we can solidify Blade as town. He said and proved that he has no vote, and I don't think Jeff would have given that kind of role to scum.

The only other people that stood out to me are Pence and Biggs. Pence, simply because he's been so...sparse, and when he speaks, he doesn't add much more than cloudy comments just to make it seem like he's paying attention. Could just be he's only speaking every so often, trying to hang back and go unnoticed.

Biggs only stands out because of his PR. And this is where I could be wrong, but I don't see anyone else with a PR. Just seems fishy that Biggs is the only one given a PR. I say I could be wrong because I'm not too familiar with South Park, so there could be someone else with one that I am overlooking. But if not, the fact that we only have one seems to be odd.

[President Jeff]

I'm replacing Blade with Branden Harvey. Harvey was first to reply to the replacement thread, so thats why he's back in. He will have Blades role in the game.

[Level-Two]

Yeah, Rebel. You hit the nail right on the head, bro. I killed two of three people named by Harvey, just to make sure I didn't look like I was scum; oblivious to the fact that if I wasn't killed next, it wouldn't stand out as suspicious at all. While I was it, I capped JamesV just to keep up with the theme of killing everyone surrounding me and making sure it was overtly obvious that I was guilty.

If you're going to vote for me, fine--but come up with something better then that. I could see this argument coming a mile away in the event I wasn't night killed last night. I knew if I wasn't killed, I'd be next in line for a frame up. I don't know if this makes Rebel scum; but I'm eager to see how others react.

[Nova]

Actually, I think I can trust Lester...never thought I would say that, but I mean it just seems like he is being made the fall guy by obvious night actions. He has really given me no reason to think he is suspiscous and at this point I would rather not throw someone under the bus that my feelings say could be scum, but my brain is saying could be town. So, who do we vote for? Well, I think Biggs could possibly be are guy or maybe possibly Blade, but at this point those seem to be the best two options we have so we have to make the best of what we have and so far it seems pretty solid to vote for either Blade or Biggs, but I will wait a bit longer to vote.

As for myself, well we could always lynch me! But then we might be in the hole a bit more, but it is up to you guys if you want to vote me out or not, your decision.

[brandenharvey]

Look, guys. A confession from L1.

I don't think Biggs is scum. Here's why:



For those that are unfamiliar with South Park, Biggs is obviously Jimmy. I can't see Jimmy being scum. Unless he's the hopped up on steroids Jimmy from the Special Olympics episode. But that's the only episode, out of several hundred, that Jimmy could have conceivably been a villian in.

[C.J. Gates]

The only reason why I brought it up, Harvey, is because he's been the only one with a PR (that I can see anyways). Just seems odd that one guy would have a PR and no one else would...

[Level-Two]

Aug 18, 2011 20:07:12 GMT -4 C.J. Gates said:

The only reason why I brought it up, Harvey, is because he's been the only one with a PR (that I can see anyways). Just seems odd that one guy would have a PR and no one else would...

I don't know why you'd think there would be a need to have more then one PR role in such a small game. If Biggs is scum using a P/R to hide himself, it's beyond brilliant but that to me is just to much of a stretch.

[President Jeff]

Day 4 ends tonight folks

[President Jeff]

like 8 hours left guys. Looks like The Town people want to lose

[brandenharvey]

C'mon guys. Vote for someone. I would but I replaced Blade.

[C.J. Gates]

Aug 19, 2011 0:22:27 GMT -4 Level-Two said:

I don't know why you'd think there would be a need to have more then one PR role in such a small game. If Biggs is scum using a P/R to hide himself, it's beyond brilliant but that to me is just to much of a stretch.

I know it was a big stretch. I was just pointing out things I noticed while reading back.

Though on that, and with the deadline coming up, I am going to place my vote on the other one I found suspicious. I doubt it will lead to much with only like, 6 hours left, but Pence really hasn't done much to help, and has really just been sitting back.

So...
Vote: Pence/Nova

[Level-Two]

Sorry, guys. At this point, lynches aren't going to happen and I honestly don't know who to vote for at this point. And considering, the kills done so far have been done to implicate me in some way, I'm not going to give scum more to work with with little benefit in return.

I'd just urge you all to use the most out of your night roles if anyone still has one.

[biggs]

I-if we do-DO-Don't lynch anyone tonight, than Mafia wins for sure. R-r-right now, I would lean towards Pence or Level-One. P-p-particluarly Lester because he said we shouldn't lynch, which would have Mafia win the game for sure. B-b-b-Based on that, I have no ch-ch-choice but to vote for him.

Vote: Level-One

Also, in regards to the PR, m-many of you have sa-sai-said you weren't familiar with the show, hence the lack of noticable PR's. I shouldn't be p-p-penalized for my knowledge of the show.

Anybody who v-v-v-votes for me likes fishsticks in their mouth, which makes them a gay fish!

[Kurt]

I don't even think L1 is scum, but for God's sake, we need something.

Vote: L1