|
|
Post by T-Marv on Mar 6, 2012 11:30:13 GMT -4
unvoteUnvoteI would have done so sooner but I've been sleeeping. I'm amazed the joke vote bandwagon got as far as it did, lol. Well, at least it saved us all from a dull day one, ha. I am not going to Role Claim just yet (mainly with all the votes and unvotes I don't know I'm at half) and secondly, if I have a good role, I don't want to out myself to scum (remember when you called me out for rolefishing 2 games ago blade?) and if I have a shit role like "vanilla" then nobody would believe me anyways. Also, roleclaiming on day one is useless... I can be counterclaimed with no proof (i.e. night action targets) to back me up. I don't think anybody seriously expected you to T-Marv, it was just a bit of banter and I thought it would be taken as obviously so. Was it banter? Or was it scum trying to roll fish in the disguise of a joke. Callahan: WTF is up with you? You went after me the first game, and you're doing it again this game. Some of the attacks are getting a little personal! Did I wrong you in some past life or are you just an all in all prick in these games? Vote: CallahanNo, this is not an OMGUS vote on you, there is reasoning behind it. 1. you jumped off my bandwaggon and called me suspect for calling it a bandwaggon in the first place. (FYI 3 quick votes like that IS a bandwaggon.) THen jumped right back on once it picked up steam a little bit. It seems a bit more than a joke. 2. You're very aggressive early on. Granted you did the same thing last round, but this round just has a little bit of a different feel. Call it a hunch. 3. Okay, maybe it is a bit of a OMGUS vote.
|
|
|
|
Post by Kaji Fireson on Mar 6, 2012 13:03:27 GMT -4
I dunno. Right now I trust Farq way more than Callahan or Bailey.
Yeah, I kinda' went "Wait what?" at the vote on Bailey from Varga, but given how he's been acting since, I don't blame him for picking Bailey for his vote. I've got my eye on Bailey also, but (as is demonstrated by my standing vote) I see Callahan as the more suspicious for the moment, for pretty much the reasons Lester, and now T-Marv have already elucidated.
You're telling Bailey to be careful...but maybe you should take some of that medicine yourself.
|
|
|
|
Post by Anthony Bailey on Mar 6, 2012 14:00:48 GMT -4
And Knuckles joins the bandwagon of the bandwagon police lol! This just keeps getting better... ok now since u just asked for it....... first and foremost: i didnt join ANY bandwagon. notice my lack of a vote. secondly: james outs u (very well i might add) and not only r u defensive but u immediately try to throw somebody else under the bus, mainly me. unlike james, i gave u the chance to come up with a serious and logical explanation to counter act any accusation only to be thrown under the bus by u. i usually dont throw out votes on a day 1 (aside from jokes to jeff) but ur really makin it hard for me. this is ur last chance b4 u get my vote bailey.....convince me to keep it off. Knuckles, I can't convince you since you already seem sold on voting for me... And JamesV gets my vote because he called me out with no probable cause and voted for me. |
|
|
|
Post by Reaver on Mar 6, 2012 14:02:56 GMT -4
if i was sold on u bailey, ud have my vote already. since i havnt voted for anybody yet then u can safely assume that u got work to do. james DID have a liable reasoning to vote for u however.
read back and see it for urself
|
|
|
|
Post by Jules on Mar 6, 2012 14:37:36 GMT -4
Was it banter? Or was it scum trying to roll fish in the disguise of a joke. Behave yourself! |
|
|
|
Post by Johnny Rebel on Mar 6, 2012 15:28:07 GMT -4
I don't like Bailey's attitude in being questioned... it screams "I'm scum but I don't have a defense so I'll just give up."
|
|
|
|
Post by President Jeff on Mar 6, 2012 20:30:26 GMT -4
I really have nothing to add right now. Its day 1, we have nothing to go on. Right now, no one screams scum to me. I'll unvote Tmarv since the joke is over now
Unvote: Tmarv
|
|
|
|
Post by Kaji Fireson on Mar 6, 2012 21:20:51 GMT -4
On the contrary, I think we have plenty to go on. Bailey's strangely defeatist play, Callahan's shady bandwagon jumping (both on and off), and though I agree with T-Marv from this side of time, his reaction to the bandwagon was rather pronounced.
Additionally, this whole kerfuffle has allowed us to start seeing who is going to be at the front lines and who is going to be more subdued in their play. Whether that makes them scum or not is an endless debate, but perhaps useful to us today when we had this maelstrom of activity surrounding T-Marv, even if it seems to be dying down.
|
|
|
|
Post by jasonandrews on Mar 6, 2012 22:57:39 GMT -4
Vote: BaileyDon't like the bandwagoning. I have a question! Why are you voting for Bailey? I mean, I like the bandwagoning about as much as you do, which is to say not at all...but why are you voting for Bailey? He's vote #5. (Six if you count Callahan's first vote which he unvoted...and then immediately revoted for some reason). He's not the vote that puts T-Marv in roleclaim range...he's clearly not driving the wagon...so why Bailey and not, say, Jeff or Farquhar? ok i just got caught up somewhat and it seems all of these finger pointings started off right about there i can pretty much say that he voted for bailey because everyone else was bandwagonning did have to vote no but i am pretty sure that was a joke vote like all the rest but on to bailey you have been quite defensive and callahan has been jumping on votes as soon as he sees a following which is something i have noticed as well so i came up wtih a list of possible scum as the game goes forward my list may or may not come to flourition this is just based off how the came has been played thus far \ (callahan,bailey,kaji,tmarv) The reason for adding kaji to the mix simply because he is adding more fuel to the fire as well as tmarv |
|
|
|
Post by Kaji Fireson on Mar 6, 2012 23:15:49 GMT -4
No offense dude...but your logic makes no damn sense.
"Based on how the game has been played so far...Callahan and Bailey seem scummy. Also Kaji and T-Marv, because they're adding fuel to the fire."
Well...if Callahan and Bailey are scum, and we're adding fuel to the fire for them to be burnt at the stake...how does that make us bad?
Granted, I'm playing more aggressively than I usually do, but T-Marv--I think--is completely justified in being as defensive as he is. He almost got lynched in the joke phase, and you were on that bandwagon. You didn't start it (J-Reb, who I think is innocent as yet), you weren't driving it (Callahan), but you were on it.
|
|
|
|
Post by Anthony Bailey on Mar 6, 2012 23:38:30 GMT -4
I don't like Bailey's attitude in being questioned... it screams "I'm scum but I don't have a defense so I'll just give up." You gotta be defensive when your back's against the wall and you don't even know how it got there in the first place  |
|
|
|
Post by Kurt on Mar 7, 2012 0:41:06 GMT -4
 "If you think I'm gonna climb through a broken window in a $30 suit, you've got another thing coming buster."- Rusty Galloway : Blade - 1 (CJ Gates) Tmarv - 1 (Callahan) Callahan - 2 (Kaji, Tmarv) Bailey – 1 (JamesV) JamesV – 1 (Bailey) Not voting: Knuckles, L1, Sally, Dusk, Blade, Farquhar, Rebel, Bacon, Jeff Note #1: I had the deadline day wrong (Day 1 ends on the 8th technically, but the hours count has been correct. There are 24 hours left in Day 1)
Note #2: Bailey, if you want to vote for someone, format it like this: (Vote: Kurt Noble). I’ve counted your bolding of James’s name, just make sure you follow that format later on.
Day 1 will end at 12 AM Midnight on March 8th (24 hours). With 15 alive, you need 8 votes for a lynch.
|
|
|
|
Post by C.J. Gates on Mar 7, 2012 0:52:03 GMT -4
I know it was nothing more than a joke but since that phase is done I'm going to Unvote: Blade.
As far as anything more to add, i don't think I have anything more than the obvious right now, what with it being day one. I think that Bacon's finger pointing at Kaji is probably off, since Kaji hasn't done anything but state a few observations. Other than the obvious ones that have already been pointed out, no one else is really jumping out at me.
|
|
|
|
Post by Blade on Mar 7, 2012 5:04:36 GMT -4
I have a fair bit to add. Dropping the mrs off at work and then I will be back. Got a fair bit to say
|
|
|
|
Post by Kurt on Mar 7, 2012 9:58:05 GMT -4
Note #1: Dusk has been replaced by Phil Atken.
Note #2: If there are no objections, I'd like to end the day phase a few hours early later on tonight. I will not be around the call the deadline, and won't be able to for 12-14 hours afterwards. I'd be ending the day about 3-4 hours early, so slightly less than 12 hours from this post. I think this will prevent the game from slowing down, but if anyone objects and absolutely needs those extra 3 hours, PM me.
|
|
|
|
Post by Phil Atken on Mar 7, 2012 10:05:50 GMT -4
Hello everyone! It's me! A person!
So thankfully I didn't have much to catch up upon, a lot of early bandwagoning nonsense and tomfoolery but I think that the following vote is a good vote:
vote: Bailey
His reaction to James' vote and really all posts since James' vote just strike me as slightly off-kilter. It seems to be overly defensive and although there's an issue in mafia of being labeled as "defensive" when you answer cases against you, he isn't even doing that. He's just trying to bat it off and be coy while still trying to hound the votee in doing so.
|
|
|
|
Post by T-Marv on Mar 7, 2012 10:14:51 GMT -4
Yeah, you're damn right I got defensive.
I got 6 votes on me on a damn joke.... and not many people seemed to think this was a problem.
Now, Callahan has dissapeared, maybe because he realizes that he was found out, maybe because his scum mates told him to STFU....but he's been on the boards and hasn't answered any of the accusations.....
GUILTY!
|
|
|
|
Post by Phil Atken on Mar 7, 2012 10:20:21 GMT -4
I would say Callahan is certainly viable, his reaction to the car crash that was the bandwagon on you is equally as odd as Bailey's.
However, between the two, something just strikes me as odd at Bailey's play being "ME? GUILTY? HOW DARE YOU THIS IS POPPYCOCK" but not in those words. It's day 1 so there's not too much to go on but so far I'd say Bailey and Callahan are viable votes.
|
|
|
|
Post by T-Marv on Mar 7, 2012 10:40:37 GMT -4
I'm okay with either a Bailey or a Callahan Lynch today. Both seem suspicious. But I don't want Callahan lost in the fold. I fear his scum mates may be trying to push a Bailey lynch to get the heat off of him....
But I agree...I'm not keen on Bailey's "Well you made up your mind so why change it?" Defense. But it does seem a little "I give up" which just doesn't feel like a scum play to me... at least not this early.
Where as completely shutting up and letting your team do the work for you (Callahan) seems scummy as hell.
|
|
|
|
Post by Michael Jennings on Mar 7, 2012 11:09:13 GMT -4
ok now since u just asked for it....... first and foremost: i didnt join ANY bandwagon. notice my lack of a vote. secondly: james outs u (very well i might add) and not only r u defensive but u immediately try to throw somebody else under the bus, mainly me. unlike james, i gave u the chance to come up with a serious and logical explanation to counter act any accusation only to be thrown under the bus by u. i usually dont throw out votes on a day 1 (aside from jokes to jeff) but ur really makin it hard for me. this is ur last chance b4 u get my vote bailey.....convince me to keep it off. Knuckles, I can't convince you since you already seem sold on voting for me... And JamesV gets my vote because he called me out with no probable cause and voted for me. Have you ever played mafia before? Because if so you'd see how shady your bandwagoning was as well as your reactions to it. Your OMGUS vote has me sold on you as well as your overreaction to a mere one vote being placed on you. All of those things are scum tells. |
|
|
|
Post by Michael Jennings on Mar 7, 2012 11:11:40 GMT -4
I don't like Bailey's attitude in being questioned... it screams "I'm scum but I don't have a defense so I'll just give up." You gotta be defensive when your back's against the wall and you don't even know how it got there in the first place I missed this gem. How the hell is your back against the wall with ONLY ONE VOTE ON YOU?! It's only day one and you're acting like you have 6 votes on you already. |
|
|
|
Post by Reaver on Mar 7, 2012 11:13:56 GMT -4
this certainly is interesting.....
wheres sally and L-O? what abput those who havnt said anything?
|
|
|
|
Post by Reaver on Mar 7, 2012 11:18:25 GMT -4
ebwop
i notice L-O's name wasnt on the write up as voting or not voting.....typo or did something happen?
|
|
|
|
Post by Kurt on Mar 7, 2012 11:25:59 GMT -4
ebwop i notice L-O's name wasnt on the write up as voting or not voting.....typo or did something happen? Not voting: Knuckles, L1, Sally, Dusk, Blade, Farquhar, Rebel, Bacon, Jeff |
|
|
|
Post by Kaji Fireson on Mar 7, 2012 12:53:48 GMT -4
I'm okay with either a Bailey or a Callahan Lynch today. Both seem suspicious. But I don't want Callahan lost in the fold. I fear his scum mates may be trying to push a Bailey lynch to get the heat off of him.... But I agree...I'm not keen on Bailey's "Well you made up your mind so why change it?" Defense. But it does seem a little "I give up" which just doesn't feel like a scum play to me... at least not this early. Where as completely shutting up and letting your team do the work for you (Callahan) seems scummy as hell.*ding* |
|
|
|
Post by Kaji Fireson on Mar 7, 2012 12:55:24 GMT -4
Also, I meant to put this in my first post, but it's not really relevant, so it's odd to be an EBWOP...but now I typed it anyway, so it kind of is...
ANYWAY
I am okay with the shortening of day one. My vote's still on Callahan, and it's gonna' stay there unless he comes back in and does something magical to convince me to take it off.
|
|
|
|
Post by Level-Two on Mar 7, 2012 14:25:32 GMT -4
this certainly is interesting..... wheres sally and L-O? what abput those who havnt said anything? What? I've said enough. It's day one and I barely care. Anyways, I don't like the concept of day one lynches but I also do not like when players clusterfuck the playingfeild by acting like they're MVP mafia players capable of working jedi mind tricks through their sarcastic responses and replies. The only reason why I think Callahan is actually a better vote than Bailey is because his hop on and hop off the ''joke'' lynch bandwaggon. Bailey still hasn't STFU so I think it's a more of a decent indication he's on his own seeing it's also his first game. Callahan however at the very least wanted to spice the game up by pushing T-Marv to six votes because it was an opportunity ''too good to pass up on'' so surely, he'll be okay with the same treatment. Vote: Callahan |
|
|
|
Post by Kurt on Mar 7, 2012 16:51:10 GMT -4
Day 1 Vote Count:
Tmarv - 1 (Callahan)
Callahan - 3 (Kaji, Tmarv, L1)
Bailey – 2 (JamesV, Atken)
JamesV – 1 (Bailey)
Not voting: Knuckles, Sally, Blade, Farquhar, Rebel, Bacon, Jeff, CJ Gates
Day 1 will end at 8 PM on March 7th (4 hours). With 15 alive, you need 8 votes for a lynch.
|
|
|
|
Post by jasonandrews on Mar 7, 2012 17:17:55 GMT -4
this certainly is interesting..... wheres sally and L-O? what abput those who havnt said anything? What? I've said enough. It's day one and I barely care. Anyways, I don't like the concept of day one lynches but I also do not like when players clusterfuck the playingfeild by acting like they're MVP mafia players capable of working jedi mind tricks through their sarcastic responses and replies. vote callahanThe only reason why I think Callahan is actually a better vote than Bailey is because his hop on and hop off the ''joke'' lynch bandwaggon. Bailey still hasn't STFU so I think it's a more of a decent indication he's on his own seeing it's also his first game. Callahan however at the very least wanted to spice the game up by pushing T-Marv to six votes because it was an opportunity ''too good to pass up on'' so surely, he'll be okay with the same treatment. You do make a great point at least Bailey is defending himself where as callahan has kind of been quiet maybe talking amongst his fellow scum? who knows but i say this would be a a first good vote Vote:Callahan |
|
|
|
Post by Kurt on Mar 7, 2012 17:24:32 GMT -4
What? I've said enough. It's day one and I barely care. Anyways, I don't like the concept of day one lynches but I also do not like when players clusterfuck the playingfeild by acting like they're MVP mafia players capable of working jedi mind tricks through their sarcastic responses and replies. vote callahanThe only reason why I think Callahan is actually a better vote than Bailey is because his hop on and hop off the ''joke'' lynch bandwaggon. Bailey still hasn't STFU so I think it's a more of a decent indication he's on his own seeing it's also his first game. Callahan however at the very least wanted to spice the game up by pushing T-Marv to six votes because it was an opportunity ''too good to pass up on'' so surely, he'll be okay with the same treatment. You do make a great point at least Bailey is defending himself where as callahan has kind of been quiet maybe talking amongst his fellow scum? who knows but i say this would be a a first good vote Vote:CallahanYou may not edit your posts (use 'EBWOP' to 'edit' them). This is your first and only warning. |
|
Unvote
