SAW Mafia Game Thread

[Phil Atken]

Knuckles if you spent more time actually realising, much like during the L-1 vote that the simplest explanation is normally the correct one, you'd be far less suspect to me.

Again, there is no reason for town to lie about there night actions. If they were caught lying, they'd be lynched. So if we are assuming Jeff wasn't openly harming the town with his actions, I think we can assume Nunez was jailed.

It's also like you want to keep the window open on Nunez, just in case people bite.

[Reaver]

the only thing i care about is catching the last scum and finishing this game.

maybe ur rite and im over thinking things. but again i dont think it was nunez or jeff. i said my piece on who it may be....

[Phil Atken]

well it'd be very hard for it to be Jeff

[Phil Atken]

Actually, I'm going to have to step back from Blade due to tragically metagaming reasons.

For the same reason that Metro could be scum from metagaming, Blade can't be scum. If Noble had let Havok back in the game switching from scum to town, it'd be... yeah.

[Blade]

So a voteless townie isn't a town role? I never said there wasn't 2 parts to it.

Think about it.

IF knuck's had been lynched, we would have learnt that he was scum or town. If he turned up town, we would have been back at square 1 today, just like we are now, because from 4/5 nights, no one can provide anything of any use.

[Phil Atken]

We would not have been at square one.

We would have information.

Lynching gives us information

You took away information.

Knuckles still alive though, that gives us no information. It still leaves a giant question mark over knuckles due to Vargas role and you know what. It leaves at square one.

You are too reliant on night actions for this game Blade, you really are.

If knuckles was lynched and he flipped town, we could have then looked back at the people who exploited the knuckles/Varga situation, we could have tried to find links to people pushing to talk about it because quite likely one of the people pushing to make it an issue instead of L-1 would be scum.

If knuckles was lynched and he was scum well...

So yes. You buggered us on your own whims. Thank you again.

[Phil Atken]

Honestly, if it wasn't for metagame, you'd almost be my top choice for today.

[Phil Atken]

Well actually metagaming and the fact I'm certain I know what your character is now.

[Phil Atken]

Although to be honest, having a secret vote while making a song and dance about not having a vote isn't particularly pro-town either.

[Arcadia]

so what is the vote count so far?

[jc]

vote: knuckles

As much as you want to point attention my way, I'm not the one trying to pull poorly thought out reasons A's to why someone else must be scum. Jeff didn't lie about using his ability, because Nunez confirmed it when he said he knew Jeff targeted him. I don't have a night ability, but I've been helping the town this entire game and if it were not for me we wouldn't be where we are right now in this game.

Now, you guys want more proof...

READ THE WRITE UP!!!!!!

The person that we saved from his test was not revealed as a member of our town, he was an unknown entity. Just some guy, where the rest of us have a name.

The corrupt politician.

The redneck.

The recluse.

Why would the person we saved(knuckles), not be labeled the same way we are. Can we please lynch the dang scum and win this game already?

[Reaver]

we saved? u may be reading it from the write up but YOU didnt save shit JC. if anything u been trying push me in front of bus since day 2. and if u took the time to read wat was written instead of skimming then ud realize that wat ive said is anything BUT poorly thought out. everything ive said has merit and speaks FACTS!! unlike u who does nuttn more around here other than troll and point fingers. that to me is scummy and ur getting angry that im seeing rite thru ur bs.

as far as the write up, i was at the lynch meaning that jeff used his ability on me last nite as a last ditch effort. in which case it would have had me on lock down. THEREFORE I COULDNT BE SCUM CUZ MY ROLE WOULD HAVE BEEN BLOCKED AND THEREFORE WOULD HAVE BEEN NO NK!!

whatever it was that happened, somebody still had the ability to send in a kill sending jeff to the crapper. is this making sense to anybody yet?

[Reaver]

ebwop....


just to clarify, by ur own logic JC, according to the write up IM the unknown guy rite? and if thats the case then jeff gave his life to save mine.

[Jesse Nuñez™]

Nov 26, 2011 7:08:28 GMT -4 Reaver said:

second: my opinion is that jeff lied about using his ability the whole game cuz he didnt wanna look scummy even tho nobody suspected him. chances r, he didnt use his ability on nunez either and said he did just to not look suspect which in turn, got him NK'd.

im not calling out nunez but i still feel JC is our guy. i think we all need to really band together and focus so we can finish this game for the town.

I already confirmed earlier in the game that Jeff did visited me when he said he did.

I also don't think it was JC either as I believe him when he has no night role.

I also still don't think it is Knuckles yet. I don't understand how he wasn't lynched when we voted for him to be killed. I don't believe the unknown guy we saved was Knuckles however. As I think maybe that was Metro we saved to bring him into the house officially and that was obviously used as a write up to kill Jeff as well.

[Reaver]

Nov 26, 2011 17:22:41 GMT -4 Jesse Nuñez™ said:

Nov 26, 2011 7:08:28 GMT -4 Reaver said:

second: my opinion is that jeff lied about using his ability the whole game cuz he didnt wanna look scummy even tho nobody suspected him. chances r, he didnt use his ability on nunez either and said he did just to not look suspect which in turn, got him NK'd.

im not calling out nunez but i still feel JC is our guy. i think we all need to really band together and focus so we can finish this game for the town.

I already confirmed earlier in the game that Jeff did visited me when he said he did.

I also don't think it was JC either as I believe him when he has no night role.

I also still don't think it is Knuckles yet. I don't understand how he wasn't lynched when we voted for him to be killed. I don't believe the unknown guy we saved was Knuckles however. As I think maybe that was Metro we saved to bring him into the house officially and that was obviously used as a write up to kill Jeff as well.

thats def a possibility

[Kurt]

Vote Count:
Knuckles - 4 (Arcadia, Atken, JC, XXX)
JC - 1 (Knuckles)

***With 4 votes, Knuckles will be tested.***

Write-up coming up just a bit later tonight.

[Kurt]

SAW MAFIA
Day 6 – Day

The group stands around this man that they have just saved.

The Corrupt Politician: Jesus, I hope he’s still alive…

The Redneck: Yeah, because I want to get the Hell out of here! How’s this guy supposed to help-

Suddenly, the man begins to cough! He wakes up, and looks around, unaware of his surroundings.

?: What…what happened to me?

The Gossiper: You nearly burned to death. We managed to save you from being boiled. Who are you anyway?

?: I…I don’t remember. I don’t remember anything before now…

The group helps the man up, as the Redneck shakes his head.

The Redneck: Great. We risk our fucking necks to save this guy, and what good does he do us?

The Gossiper: You risk your neck? I didn’t see you taking a flame shower to save him!

The Recluse: What’s that around your neck?

The group stares at his neck, revealing a necklace…

?: I…don’t know.

The Survivor: Wait a second… maybe it’s a key to a door out of here! At the start there was those large locked doors, so maybe we had to save you to get the key!

The Peeping Tom: Can’t hurt to try…

They take the key, and help the man up. The group wanders out of the room, and back to the original starting room. The Survivor takes the key, and uses it to open the doors. Inside is another room…and standing in the middle of it is one man.

Jigsaw: Greeting everyone. Congratulations on surviving your tests. I am the one you know as “Jigsaw.”

The group stands silently before the man that placed them in this Hell house.

Jigsaw: I can only hope that the past few hours have given you a …reflection on your lives up to this point. I gave you each a chance to erase the mistakes you’ve made, and the hurt you’ve placed upon others. You made your own decisions, and are the survivors.

The Redneck: Bullshit! What about all the guys that didn’t make it out of your Goddamn trap! Your apprentices killed them, and we killed your apprentices!

Jigsaw: Death was never the ultimatum in your games. Every trap you encountered could have been solved by coming together as a group to bear the agony that was placed on one. The only person maliciously murdered was my Vengeful Apprentice…but his death came from bitter rivalries with another apprentice of mine. Their deaths were unfortunate, but I assure you…one remains to carry out my work. In fact, he stands among you.

The group faces one another, their eyes lined with distrust.

Jigsaw: The one you are looking for is the man that you have just saved. He is my Secret Apprentice. Now, I offer you one final game. It’s time to test how valuable your lives really are. One of you has the means to kill this man, but know that you would not be in a situation to escape without him. You can let him live, or kill him.

The Secret Apprentice: This is BULLSHIT-

Jigsaw: This is your game. Your life is in their hands. Live or Die…the group makes your choice.

The Redneck: You gave me this at the start of this game, but I knew I had to save it for you. And what’s to stop me from killing you both?

The Redneck then pulls out a gun! It’s pointed right at Jigsaw, but he makes no motion to move.

Jigsaw: Because there are rules, and as you’ve learned…breaking them has serious consequences. Killing me will not resolve your vengeance, nor will it correct your life.

Jigsaw motions towards the Secret Apprentice, and he stands before the group.

The Secret Apprentice: Jesus Christ, I didn’t do anything to any of you! I…I have a family, and I just want a chance to go home-

The Survivor: You put us here!

The Peeping Tom: But…to be fair, he didn’t actually do anything to us that we know of. If we didn’t save him, we might not have gotten out-

The Recluse: Bullshit! He’s with Jigsaw, so he deserves to die!

The Corrupt Politician: Let him go…let’s just go home guys.

The Gossiper: We have to make the decision as a group guys…this is what our game was about. So what’re we doing guys?

The group stands around, as the Redneck aims the gun at the Secret Apprentice.

The Corrupt Politician: Just put the gun down, and we’ll go-

BAM!

DEAD: Knuckles/The Secret Apprentice (#8) – Mafia Miller

Jigsaw closes his eyes as his last remaining apprentice drops dead from the gunshot.

The Redneck: It’s done. Now we’re getting the fuck out of here.

Jigsaw: You are “free” to go. No more traps lie before you.

The Corrupt Politician: Can we trust you?

Jigsaw: I never lied to you in your game. I gave you information, and it was your choice to trust it or to discard it. The truth was right in front of you…hopefully as it is now. You cannot live your life in hatred towards others.

Jigsaw begins to walk away towards another door. He stands before the remainders.

Jigsaw: Some people are so ungrateful to be alive…but not you…not anymore. Game over.

Jigsaw closes the door behind him, as the remainders stand over the dead body of the Secret Apprentice. They’ve won their game…

Right?

WINNERS: THE PLAYERS/TOWN

*FALLOUT THREAD COMING SOON*